1. TOBS Mr. Taylor's
2. SCS Extract of Limes
3. Dominica Bay Rum with Lime
DR Harris Marlborough sometimes bubbles up into the top three, and I like the scent of Arlington shaving cream, so I suspect I'd like the a/s. Judging by the love for Alt-Innsbruck, I'm going to have to hit up Garry for a sample.
However, as I was typing this the mail arrived and with it Speick and Booster Mosswood, so this list may change next week. Now I wish that I had waited to shave.