Aftershave without alcohol and menthol?

[Iridian]

It seems I developed an irritating skin condition, which might be rosacea, still have to check with a doc hopefully next week.

Unfortunately, some of my usual ingredients in all my favorite aftershaves are ideally to be avoided, at least for a time to check what triggers my skin to overreact:

Alcohol & Menthol

I am looking for aftershaves and balms that contain neither.

 

[Wombat ESQ]

Water
Carbonated Water
Perrier

 

[tomas1870]

I didn't use any aftershave more.

For me works best warm water, cold water, alum block, cold water again and after hazel witch with aloe without alcohol (Thayers unscented).

I shave normally morning, evening I clean my face with Weleda Klärendes Waschgel, and finally apply CeraVe Moisturizing Cream. This is for this period, in winter use more moisturizing, also morning after shave if needed

 

[Kristho]

Maybe: Nivea Sensitive Aftershave Balm?

 

[NorthernSoul]

Dickinson's Witch Hazel Hydrating Toner. I use this one along with regular aftershave, but it works pretty well by itself.

Provence Sante Green Tea aftershave. This one is soothing and has a light fragrance.

 

[Iridian]

Maybe: Nivea Sensitive Aftershave Balm?

I am currently using that, I still had one in my shaving cabinet. It fits the bill, I am fishing for something a little more exciting and to my liking.

 

[Kristho]

I am currently using that, I still had one in my shaving cabinet. It fits the bill, I am fishing for something a little more exciting and to my liking.

Yeah, it's definately more of a work horse, than pure excitement

 

[musicman1951]

I use Thayer's unscented toner with aloe, which has neither ingredient.

 

[mfury]

I am currently using that, I still had one in my shaving cabinet. It fits the bill, I am fishing for something a little more exciting and to my liking.

That Nivea caused me to break out with the Rosacea like blotches after a few days of use.

 

[sarimento1]

 

[nelsonic21]

Stirling has a line of witch hazel and aloe post shave splashes.

 

[Slapo]

I've used Eclat organic aloe vera gel as an aftershave occasionally, and it was decent at that.

 

[Mr Konrad Dundee]

I'm very sorry about your skin, I hope you can resolve it as soon as possible
As suggested above, I recommend using a product without any added fragrance
Organic witch hazel hydrolate "alcohol-free" and an unscented balm

 

[FullBoar]

Zingari Man’s Recovery Splash is very nice on the skin.

Murphy and McNeil offer alcohol-free versions of their splashes.

MacDuff’s and Southern Witchcrafts are alcohol-free.

Nivea Sensitive splash.

Lucky Tiger (calendula and aloe)

 

[Opolar]

Lea 0% alcohol aftershave lotion.

 

[DEgeezer]

Lucky Tiger fits the bill. No alcohol or menthol.

 

[reformedshavr]

DR Harris Pink is super mellow, made for sensitive skin, but more exciting than witch hazel - it does contain some amount of alcohol, but I've never felt any kind of burn or sting.

 

[Jaybyrd]

I just got this from Pasteurs Pharmacy and really like it a lot. The scent is unique and my wife and kids have complimented it. My son asked if he could have (he’s 15 doesn’t shave YeT but likes the graphics I think).

 

[Iridian]

I am going to get Lucky Tiger "Aspen", it's blue, but only a food color.

I was at the dermatologist and she told me to stop googling my diagnosis and stated it's not rosacea but neurodermitis. Alcohol and menthol are unlikely reasons, a so called ***** test is yet to be made in a few days.

@mfury I am not a fan of nivea or other balms either. I like the quick drying aspect of alcoholic aftershave.

For my Lambda Athena shave I will use the rehabilitated Dorco Prime blades tonight, and follow @tomas1870 's suggestion to simply use NOTHING, no aftershave.

The Tiger stuff will likely arrive before the next shave, though.

 

[BigJ]

Another vote for Lucky Tiger (and I prefer the ‘classic’ orange scent)!!