What's your favorite Mama Bear soap scent?

[neilz4]

I'm very intrigued by a lot of the scents, but I'm also overwhelmed by the sheer selection. I'd love to get a hold of two or three, but to ship two tubs to CA is $10! And shipping one is $3.14. Not to mention the $150 I just spent on various things due to AD. Ugh...the bug...

Anyways. Can you gentlemen help me refine my choices? I'm not much into floral or powdery. I like soft and warm scents like vanilla and most of the wood (and woody type) scents. Citrus is also nice to me, too.

 

[JRobinhood]

I think you should give "Northwoods" a shot. It has a pine and very light musk scent that finishes with a woodsy/earthy scent, I really enjoy it.

 

[charles_r]

I'm very intrigued by a lot of the scents, but I'm also overwhelmed by the sheer selection. I'd love to get a hold of two or three, but to ship two tubs to CA is $10! And shipping one is $3.14. Not to mention the $150 I just spent on various things due to AD. Ugh...the bug...

Anyways. Can you gentlemen help me refine my choices? I'm not much into floral or powdery. I like soft and warm scents like vanilla and most of the wood (and woody type) scents. Citrus is also nice to me, too.

Shipping two tubs is more expensive per tub than shipping just the one? Are you sure? How odd!!! I would just place separate orders for each tub
I have Mama Bear's Citrus Basil and it's very nice.

 

[ironfisted]

I'm currently in love with the lime ice. The citrus smell picks me up and the menthol is really nice and cooling. It's the only one I have at the moment, but I ordered 6 tubs the other day, during the great Mama Bear Closing Panic, and I'm looking forward to trying them. On the way are 2 x Lemon Ice, 2 x Czar's Choice Lime Cilantro, and 2 x Caribbean Bay Rum. The Czar's Choice seems to have a pretty big following and I just really want a Bay Rum scent, so hopefully I'll love those ones too. If not, expect to see them PIF'ed.

 

[Arcadies]

Spellbound Woods and Ye Olde Barbershoppe are pure heaven. I can rarely use them though, due to them setting my face on fire.

 

[Rev. Jim Ignatowski]

Sandalwood Vanilla. Great scent.

 

[cryhavoc]

My favorite is Vanilla Musk

 

[Scott0079]

Turkish Mocha.

 

[Wolfman1]

Hydrogen.

 

[rockviper]

Sorry, I can't choose just one.... but I can name 2 that truly stand out for me ..... Lemon Rose and Northwoods

 

[kingfisher]

If you like citrus scents, try the Spicey Lime. It's really nice.

 

[SuperChris]

Aged Spice

 

[dreadpirate]

I recommend you try a shave stick (if you have not already) from Mama Bear. I tried and like the Aged Spice. Another that sounds like it would be good is the Caribbean Bay Rum.

 

[Toddy]

Anyone tried the Winter Woods?

 

[aw561838]

I really enjoy Ye Olde Barbershoppe and Masonic Lodge.

 

[Wcoppage]

Ye Olde Barbershop
Creme Brulee
Spicy Lime
Vanilla Sandlewood

I want to try the "ice" ones, esp Mandarin Ice, just cant afford to buy more soap right now.

 

[gwav64]

Caribbean Bay Rhum is the only tub of Mama Bear's that I own. It's got vetiver and cloves and spices as far as fragrance. I did a review on it in the reviews section of this website. You can also order samples from her, which is a great way to experience a lot of scents without committing to a whole tub.

 

[Mendel]

+1 Ye Old Barbershop

 

[rwdflynavy]

Ye Olde Barbershop and North Woods are both great. I have 4 more I just ordered. More to follow!!

 

[garyg]

My favorite Mama Bear is Dragon's Blood, almost in a tie with Orange, Orange. Cabin in the Woods is great also, as is Hydrogen. But as GWAV64 has already mentioned, the samples let you take a test ride.