Trying to decide between these two cologne Elsha russian leather or woods of windsor?

[jim84]

I have never smelled either and will buy one of the two as a blind buy which do you think is better?

I know there both supposed to be leathery scents


Thanks

Jim

 

[ClubmanRob]

So now you've narrowed it down from Woods of Windsor, Montana and Sierra to Woods of Windsor and El. Russian Leather.

Go with the Russian Leather if you like leather. Go with the Woods of Windsor if you like florals. I would personally go with Russian Leather.

 

[jakespoppy]

I've only sprayed the tester in-store for the Woods of Windsor, but didn't notice any leather. Did I miss it? It seemed like more of a spicy floral, if that makes sense?

 

[tsmba]

The scent of leather seems very elusive. Most frags described as "leather" bear no resemblance to the real McCoy, IMHO. The best I've tried is Tom Ford's "Tuscan Leather", which hits it well....for a time.