I am not familiar with the two A/S s you referenced but Godrej menthol cream reminds me of my Cube 2.0 menthol prep.I rediscovered an unopened tube of Godrej Cool Menthol (India).
Nice enough on its own, but then I followed it up with:
Lúcido aftershave (Japan)
Myrsol Emulsión (Spain)
Both of these ae among my favorite shaving products on the planet.