TOBS Eton College or Mr Taylor?

[nwman]

i've tried all the tobs cologne scented creams, eton college is my favorite.
that being said they're all pretty mild scent-wise so don't sweat it too much.

 

[joto]

Both are nice, however in an either/ or situation I give the edge to Eton on scent.

 

[bhsher]

Makes me want to try some Eton College now. I'm currently using Sandalwood and like it pretty well. It's my real shaving cream and haven't been sorry.

 

[Gafer]

Ok, which one would be more suitable for a man in his late 20's early 30's? Which one do you prefer?

Having tried samples of all of the TOBS creams here are my personal rankings based on performance and scent:
Avocado~1
Eton College~2
Lemon-Lime~8
Shave Shop~3
Rose~6
Mr. Taylors~4
St. James~5
Sandalwood~7
Lavender~9
Almond~10

I say go for both - Mr. Taylors' and Eton College. They're both nice.

 

[jpolz]

Eaton College has a lighter scent, almost a fragrance. It might make a good summer AS or cologne, but I wouldn't like it as my shaving cream. But then, I'm over 30 and don't like scented creams.

 

[Gruder]

Of the two, I vastly prefer Eton College.

 

[Pedigree]

Eton College for Spring/Summer, Mr. Taylor for Fall/Winter

 

[Steelerfan]

Mr. Taylor!