What's new

The New Guys Guide to Soaps & Creams

**Please note: This is not meant to be a product review as there is an extensive reviews section within B&B.

I had been wet shaving for many years before finding Badger & Blade and up until that time had been using whatever cheap soap I could find at the mall or online. It never really occurred to me all the myriad of products available to the mug and brush shaver. After finding B&B my eyes were opened to all the choices and possibilities to the point it all became a bit overwhelming. Most notably I became concerned how much it was all going to cost. One reads words like luxurious, imported and essential ingredients you believe it is going to cost you plenty. As you continue the investigation you start wondering is there any way the cheap puck or tube can possibly measure up to the big players? Therein lies my purpose; to assure the new wet shaver you do not have to spend great sums of money in acquiring effective soaps and creams.

By now you’ve lurked around awhile, you’ve read the sticky threads, you’ve watched the You Tube tutorials and you’ve gotten a hint what it’s all about. When I first visited B&B there was a home page story regarding cheap drugstore aftershaves and their quality and effectiveness despite the low prices. After trying numerous soaps and creams at both ends of the price spectrum I am now comfortable in claiming the same holds true for them. The cheaper products can and do provide close, comfortable and in many cases superior shaves than their more expensive cousins. For the purposes of this discussion I consider “cheaper” to mean anything under $20 though many cost far less. This seems counter intuitive as we’ve been brought up believing the maxims “you get what you pay for” or “cheap means junk”. Fortunately in this case that is simply not true. In offering the following, I make the assumption you understand many factors are at play attaining the perfect shave. Proper beard preparation, the right razor and blade, angles and correct water ratios are a few that come to mind. Also by now you’ve seen the acronym YMMV which means ‘Your Mileage May Vary’ or in other words, results vary and to each his own.

All this in mind there are only a couple bottom line characteristics we care about in a soap or cream. Does it provide a good cushion on which the razor and blade will glide? Does it provide a slippery surface to prevent the blade from skipping and pulling? Does the face feel hydrated and moisturized during and after the shave? That’s it. Details such as scent, richness, lather-ability and so on are of secondary concern to these core qualities. Qualities that I assure you are available in some very economical products. There exists one very easy process that tests all three characteristics at once. Most shavers make more than one pass with the razor. In between passes if you rinse the face with warm water in preparation for re-lathering it should feel almost satin like, smooth and slippery. I am reminded of a recently caught fish that slips and slides through the hands. This tactile feedback provides us information regarding the slickness and hydrating qualities we are looking for in a painless shave. You will immediately know when a product doesn’t meet these standards. The face will feel dull, and the hands will not easily skate over the cheeks and neck. A small amount of friction or resistance will be noted, and you will almost certainly feel a dreaded pulling and skipping of the blade as you shave. It was noted at the beginning this is not a product review. However I want to offer up just a few products I have tried that meet the above criteria. This list is certainly not all inclusive and as mentioned results will vary. Simply put they are but a few of the cheaper products available that may offer you outstanding results. At the very least if you do not like them, you will not feel cheated in discarding them as they are that cheap. If you take anything away from this at all, I would like it to be that you need not feel sheepish or ashamed in purchasing and using dirt cheap products. Quite honestly, in my experience they offer the closest and most comfortable shaves I have ever had. Prices listed are a rough average and only the most basic of ingredients are shown.

Col. Conks:
Glycerin based soap puck. Contains avocado oil and vitamin E.
Variety of scents available.
$5
View attachment 29927

Kiss My Face:
Water based cream. Contains olive oil, aloe vera and Goldenseal antiseptic.
Variety of scents available.
Natural food locations (Sprouts, Whole Foods)
$8
View attachment 29929

Tabac:
Triple milled soap puck. Contains bergamot, neroli and lavender.
$12
View attachment 29930

CO Bigelow/Proraso rebranded:
Water based cream. Eucalyptus and coconut oils and glycerin.
Bath & Body Works
$10 large tube
$5 small tube
View attachment 29926

For Men Shave Cream:
Water and glycerin based cream. Vitamins A, E and B5 and sesame seed oil.
The Body Shop
$14 tub
$10 tube
View attachment 29928

Taylor of Old Bond Street:
Water and glycerin based cream. Contains Aloe Barbadensis and Allantoin.
Variety of scents and available in soap pucks
Moisturizing effects vary by scent and formula; see product reviews first
$15
proxy.php


Van Der Hagen:
Glycerin based soap puck. Contains vitamin E and oat extract.
Also comes in Deluxe version with aloe vera and lanolin.
Available at most drug stores including Wal Greens and Wal Mart.
$2
proxy.php



Give one or all of these a try and see if you're not impressed. I'm willing to bet at least one and probably more will give you a very satisfying shave.
 
good on you Shep. I agree, you do not have to spend a fortune to get a great shave. KMF are a great lubricating creams.
 
Don't forget Van Der Hagen shaving soap ~$1.50 at your local walmart.

** The "for men" cream is actually "The Body Shop - for men Shave Cream" the logo has the first part of the name of the product **
 
Don't forget Van Der Hagen shaving soap ~$1.50 at your local walmart.

** The "for men" cream is actually "The Body Shop - for men Shave Cream" the logo has the first part of the name of the product **

That is correct. I will edit to reflect locations where applicable.
 
Great info! I'm using three of the five listed. Nothing wrong with saving a little money. I haven't tried Tabac or Conks yet but I'll put them on the list. So far I haven't been real impressed with my samples of the more expensive soaps and creams but we're all different I guess.
 
Outstanding, I found no bias and feel you are spot on with the feeling while rinsing the face between passes. Great job.
 
Thanks gents. Just some observations after several trials. Indeed I forgot about Van Der Hagen. Edited and added. Williams Mug soap is another cheap brand but it gets such mixed reviews I decided not to include it. Plus which I've never used it.

I have no idea how to create a sticky so if anyone else does go for it. Thanks again for the kind words.
 
Great idea and great work! This would have been extremely helpful when I first started. In fact, I may just have to get some of the ones on this list that I haven't tried yet!
 
You see the way many soaps come moulded into bowls... I'm new & I've just ordered Col. Conk soap "pucks" online. Do I really need to buy a bowl for them?... If so, and the bowl's not an exact fit, does it matter if the soaps sliding around a bit in the bowl?

Sorry for the really green questions.
 
no you don't need a special bowl. You can keep the puck in its blister pack. You can drop it into a coffee mug. If it is glycerin you can carefully melt it (no more than 20 seconds at a time in a microwave) and then pour it into a sealable container. You can run it through a grater, add a few drops of water and squeeze it into a container. There are threads on here on the subject.
 
The Col Conk pucks are designed so that they will fit into the bottom of a typical shaving mug, which makes for an exact fit. Many coffee cups or mugs will work for that purpose. If it scoots around a little bit, then that will only be a little bothersome when trying to load up the brush.
 
Don't forget about Wars shave cream. I can't remember the exact cost but it is around $3 a tube and is one of the slickest creams I have tried.
 
You see the way many soaps come moulded into bowls... I'm new & I've just ordered Col. Conk soap "pucks" online. Do I really need to buy a bowl for them?... If so, and the bowl's not an exact fit, does it matter if the soaps sliding around a bit in the bowl?

Sorry for the really green questions.

I have both the Amber and Almond Col. Conk pucks. I placed them in a small zip lock hard shell container and nuked them each in two 10 sec. intervals. By the time the second interval was over they were completely liquefied. Put them in the fridge for 30 mins. and they solidified to the form of the container. Have used both and they shave great.
 
Thanks guys... Would it be fair to say that a bowl would be easier to work with than a mug?... I've been using Wilkinson blue bowl soap for the last week or so which obvviously comes in it's own bowl... I like that you can turn the brush sideways etc and scoop up all the lather... Is it just personal preference?
 
Top Bottom