I have both and use them regularly as well. I find them both to be top tier performers and equally as user friendly. Love both scents. Cella is the most bang for the buck.
Why there's no "both" option?
I think that, after 32 replies, the OP has about as much information as when he started the thread.
There is only one way to find out if you like a shaving soap, and that is by trying it.
Forum posts could never have told me that I don't like the Cella scent, and that it slightly irritates my skin.
I suspect that my skin does not like the parfum (I guess it contains benzaldehyde).
Forum posts can also not tell the OP how he ranks the Tabac scent; old lady's handbag filled with cigarette remains, or a classic lavender scent, or anything inbetween
Hi, I'm still relatively new to wet shaving! Currently on tight budget and don't want to have the SAD (that is what you all called here for buying tons of shaving equipment right?), which is why I am really down to either Tabac or Cella, with purchase along with LPL and MWF.
I understand ... but a forum won't tell you which soap you like best.
Tabac.....almond soaps burn.