I tried Williams for the second time tonight. I'm no expert yet, but do see how it is more finicky than my other soaps. I added a small drop of my wife's Trader Joe's Mango Shave Cream and that perked it right up!
Proraso and any tallow hardish soap. MWF, Arko, Tabac, etc.
I have a sample of the new Proraso Eucalyptus and Menthol. I'm going to put a dab of it on Mike's Unscented for tonight's superlather. Oooh, I think this is going to be good.
I just made a superlather with Cella and Kiss My Face Lavender + Shea Butter. Best shave ever. Seriously.