What's new

Saturday night SE experiment

I know, what a pathetic thread title that is. But the wife and toddler are at her mother's so I have time to play.

Today I bought a pack of Blue Star and a pack of Treet. Used each in my Damaskene with it's spanking new (old) fat black handle.

Verdict: the Treet is noticeably smoother and cuts better. My problem areas were BBS in 2 passes, with only a few minor weeps. The Pal is the only other razor that can do that for me.

Blue Star isn't quite as good...does not feel quite as sharp and doesn't take off whiskers as fast as the Treet...but it's still better than the regular Gem stainless blades I'd bought way back when I started hanging around here. Those Gems either wouldn't cut my whiskers or ripped me up doing so. They are what caused me to write off SEs in the first place, I now realize. What's left of them is going to be relegated to the paint scraper, where they belong.

Too bad the Treets cost a buck more than the any other shaving SE, and are only available at Rite Aid, at least around here.

I now look forward to finding out how the Treets do in an open comb Micromatic I picked up, and then compare them with the Ted Pellas.

Anyway, I'm glad for the constant input from guys that cause me to reexamine what I've been doing. First I wrote off injectors b/c my technique wasn't honed yet, as I learned here...now I swear by them. Now I'm very pleased to add an SE back into my regular rotation...again, thanks to the constant experimentation you guys do. :thumbup:
 
Last edited:
The Treets are about 30 cents cheaper around here at Rite Aid than the GEM's at Walgreens- $4.99 for 10 vs $5.29 for 10 GEMs. I definitely prefer the Treets for sharpness and comfort but they fade pretty quickly after 2-3 shaves. Used one today in a Bullet Tip Micro Matic with excellent results.
 
Have you tried Blue Stars?

I've heard 2-3 good shaves out of a Treet (about what I get out of any injector blade) is usual, but it beats the zero good shaves I ever got out of those Gems! :thumbdown
 
Have you tried Blue Stars?

I've heard 2-3 good shaves out of a Treet (about what I get out of any injector blade) is usual, but it beats the zero good shaves I ever got out of those Gems! :thumbdown

No, I can't find them anywhere. I do dry the Treets and dip them in alcohol after each use, I guess that helps some.
 
Don,

Check those Blue Stars. I'll bet you they are rusting as we speak.

This thread contains photos, but it is not for the squeamish or faint of heart!

http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php?t=109868

Yeah, I saw that before. I'm keeping an eye on both, after removing both and drying carefully, I'm hopeful they don't go bad too fast. Odd, that the Gems NEVER rusted (stainless) yet never cut worth a crap for me.
 
I can't tell by looking...are Treets stainless or carbon? Alternate question: is every SE blade stainless except Blue Star?
 
I haven't tried the Blue Stars, but I will say that Treets seem to perform better in my 1912 razors than the OC.
+1 on Treets being carbon, also there are PAL blades that are carbon.
 
Day two with the Treet blade in the 1912 that's in the Old Spice mug in your rotation thread. Very nice shave today.

I'm getting ready to go for day 2 with the Treet, in the non-bullet tip, toothed Micromatic (just to see how it goes...last time I used a MM it also was with Gem blades...maybe I'll need an 8 day pipe rack when I'm done :tongue_sm )
 
And only now, 24 hours later, am I feeling stubble. Can feel it, but it's barely visible and would not make me look unshaved. Only the Pal has gotten me this close for this long. No DE ever has. Wish I understood why - it doesn't make sense - but it's a fact.
 
I can't tell by looking...are Treets stainless or carbon? Alternate question: is every SE blade stainless except Blue Star?

PAL blades are Blue Carbon Steel and those don't seem to rust as quickly as the Blue Stars. In fact, I got six good shaves from the PALs.

I believe they now come "pre-rusted for your convenience."

:lol:

That explains the nice performance, then.



Currently made? If so, wonder if they're just ASRs reboxed.

I believe PAL is owned by ASR.
 
PAL blades are Blue Carbon Steel and those don't seem to rust as quickly as the Blue Stars. In fact, I got six good shaves from the PALs.

If you're talking about the ones for $8.25 per 100 at the Ted Pella site (first time I looked) I'm definitely going to try them out.
 
I just ordered SE blades from Amazon maybe 30 minutes before seeing this thread. :-/ I ordered Blue Stars (can't seem to cancel them) and GEM Personnas. I have some Pals. Will those work in a Micromatic?
 
Top Bottom