What's new

rasoio a mano libera: Saddi Arresoia

One of the things I've been on the lookout for is an Italian Straight. I have French, Swedish, German, English, American and Japanese, but nothing from Italy. At one point, I even tried one of the Russian razors. Over the last 6 months I'd seen one or two, but nothing in my price range or something that I wanted to own.

A few weeks ago, a razor, or rather a bunch of razors, showed up from an "artisan" in Sardinia. What was odd was that some of his razors had the bidding starting at 130.00 and others, seemingly identical, had it starting at 10 bucks. Here's the pic of the razor from the listing and it's the only pic from the listing:
View attachment 373221

Not terrible looking. I was intrigued. The text description was:

good morning
have graduated mechanical engineer mechanical engineering and congegnatore.
I'm a craftsman by profession.
my products are the best craft stores in Sardinia and in the armories
I do all the pieces are unique and inimitable, because they are made one by one.
use the best materials.
handles for use: bovine tibia bone, ram's horn worked, raw ram's horn and buffalo horns.
razors blades for use carbon steel J2 HCR 60, or 512 layers Damascus blade HCR 58
to use the knife blades carbon steel 4034 HCR 58, carbon steel 440C hcr 58, carbon steel J2 HCR 58
or damascus blade 512 layers HCR 56.
all my razor or my knife has a leather sheath and certificate of warranty.
my problem is that I can not take pictures (then settle for those that do, then when you are sure that you stay acquisterette sodisfatti) and do not have much time to devote to your computer.
I have no website because I sell to shops
then aprofitate of these anunci that I put on ebay
good auction to all of you with the hope that you remain happy all
This razor is:
handle shank bone of cattle
blade 7/8 steel 1075
HCR 60
leather sheath
to contact me
mail: pi*******[email protected]
tel / fax 3********4
skype p*****i


Although stubbornly suspicious, the little touch of the contact information at the end tipped the scales. That, and the fact that there was very little information about the razors available. The bid was 10 bucks with 12 bucks shipping and while that was 2 bucks over my "WTH" limit, I figured if it could be had for 22 bucks, then I'd share what I learned with the rest of B&B in much the same way Slash is doing with the Kriegar. Besides, I didn't really think I'd win it for a ten dollar bid.

Well, I did and it arrived this past Monday. Here are the unboxing pics.

First of all, the sheath is NOT leather. Not even close. Ok. There's one born every second, but I never use those things anyway and that's not what I was paying for.
View attachment 373225

Here's the razor
View attachment 373224

The scales certainly are bone, no deception there, but they're so huge that I suspect it's the entire leg of the cow. I mean, just really, really big. Again, I had the impression that this guy was a knife maker and this is, so I've heard, a common characteristic in razors made by knife makers, so no big deal. One can always modify the scales to a more reasonable size. Besides, I was only out 22 bucks, shipped.

Here's another look at the thickness of the scales.
View attachment 373223

The wedge looked to be, maybe, bone also, but it could very well have been plastic. I can't tell. Either way, it's a botched job with the wedge. It's not angled, nor is the fit with the scales that great. It looks almost as if they filled the gap with horn powder or epoxy. Or it might be a flaw in the wedge if it's bone.

A few other things I noticed. The blade doesn't close centered and the pins don't have collars. It also appears that they were ground or sanded after being hammered because of the circular depressions around the pins. I recognize that from my early efforts in scale making. I actually liked the look of the pins,however, because it was quite rustic. On the other hand, I also know they've got to be removed in order to sand down the scales to a reasonable size and I'm already dreading having to drill them out.

So far it's clear that there's no "craftsmanship" in the assembly of the razor or the manufacture of the scales. None at all. It is strikingly careless work. I still, however, had some hope for the blade.

Here's the razor:

View attachment 373222

cont:
 
View attachment 373230

The first thing one notices is the low quality of the etching on the blade. It's like the stuff one gets on the cheap giveaways at tech conferences. The sort of etching designed for mass production. There was a hint of oil still on the razor which was promising, but the overall finish was not impressive. In fact, it looked and felt depressingly similar to a Pakistani razor I had which was impervious to my efforts to take an edge. Or, rather, to keep an edge. It would take one, but then lose it almost immediately. At this point, the optimism I'd kept carefully propped up, tottered and then fell. There is no way this was a hand forged razor. None at all. Not a single element of the razor suggested anything other than machine production. In fact, it would have taken a supremely talented razor maker to forge such a consummate counterfeit of a production razor. I don't think, however, that is what is going on.

a better view of the pinning
View attachment 373231

I have large hands, btw, so it doesn't really show the scale properly.
View attachment 373232

Attempting to put this misfortune in a glass half full perspective I said to myself "Self, at least you should be able to get a pair of bone scales out of this mess". Not an assertion I completely believed though as the little matter of drilling those pins remained and who the hell knew what they might be made of.

Running the blade across my arm hairs revealed a dead dull edge. Under the loupe, it certainly looked like a bevel was there, but one could have just as easily used the Saddi as a butter knife.

After a day to sleep on it and consider whether I should ask for a refund or not, I decided to see this through and figure out what sort of edge it would take. Since it seemed to have the beginnings of a bevel, I went straight to the Jnat and Botan and applied a fair amount of pressure. Since I still thought I might try and return it, I put a layer of tape on the spine. After a few minutes honing, I looked at the edge and could see that though the razor was laying pretty flat (not perfectly, but better than 70% of the old sheffields I get), the very edge of the razor wasn't changing. It was happening just above the very edge of the blade.

Figuring I needed to get more agressive, I moved down in grit to the Chosera 1k. Honed like a madman on that, but progress, though made, was slow. Really slow. At this point, I was getting pissed. I pulled out the DMT 325, slapped on two layers of tape and put an old fashioned hurtin' on the blade. After a couple of minutes, a bevel was born. What's more, it lopped off hair far more easily than it had a right to. This was encouraging.

After putting on fresh tape (still two layers), I moved up to the DMT 600. At this point, I noticed that though progress was certainly made and the scratch patterns from the 325 were being replaced by the 600, it took far longer than on most of the other razors I've honed that were not wedges. The only conclusion I can come to is that this was in fact very, very hard steel. Maybe even harder than RC 60.

From there on it was, except for having to double the amount of time on each progression, pretty standard. I went down to a single layer of tape on the Chosera and kept a single layer on for the rest of the progression on the Jnat. That was yesterday. Today, I stropped it 100 linen/100 leather and shaved with it.

The results were mixed. On the one hand, the edge was sharp, very sharp, but I think it could have been better. The fault, however, was mostly mine. I think I rushed it a bit and didn't really max out the edge, but make no mistake, it held an edge and I think it can hold an even better one. Part of the problem in assessing the edge, however, was those ginormous scales. They threw the whole thing out of balance. It was exceedingly hard to maintain the angle with the equivalent of an entire cow leg acting as a counterweight. I got a better than average shave and though there's no question that this is a factory razor and not a hand forged piece of art, a 7/8ths hollow ground with gigantic bone scales for 22 bucks is a pretty good deal.

The Saddi reminds me most of the Chinese Gold Dollars. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if the guy bought the razors or the blanks from China and just assembled them in Sardinia. He has other models and maybe some of those are better, but you'll have to spend your own money to find out. If anyone else here has ever tried one, I'd love to know what you thought.
 
Last edited:
Great wright-up! Let's see you put a better edge on it and THEN see how many shaves you can get out of it. Rescale that beast! Maybe just thin the scales and apply a new wedge?
 
Cool! There's definitely a lot of potential if you thin out these bone scales. I just bought some bone blanks recently and had quite a tough time finding some long enough blanks. For $22, these are pre-shaped and come with a bonus blade!
 
Nice write up,

Those scales are Huge, not a big deal as that part can be fixed.

Looking forward to further shave reports
 
Great write-up. I saw the first few of these go for $300+ and was very tempted, but couldn't find any info on them so I was reluctant to bid.
 
Great write-up. I saw the first few of these go for $300+ and was very tempted, but couldn't find any info on them so I was reluctant to bid.

David,
Would you like to try it and post your impressions? I think it would be helpful if a couple others chimed in. If so, drop me a PM. Tomorrow is mailing day and I can get it out then.
m
 
Top Bottom