What's new

Poor Feedback on Shapton Pro Stones

Shapton Pro stones are my favorite artificial whetstones. They're very expensive outside of Japan so I know that there aren't too many people who own them. However, if you do own them, then you should heed this advice.

A common complaint of owners of the #5000 - #15000 stones is that they feel slippery or give poor feedback. These stones are fast so unless you're good at edge tests, the poor feedback leads to over-honing and/or rounded edges. It can become very frustrating to use them, which is especially upsetting considering their cost.

You solve this problem by changing how you lap them. Lap them with the same coarse grit that you've always used. For most people, that's the DMT D8C #325. However, don't stop there. Go on to #1000 and then finish with #2000. Wet/dry sandpaper is easy to use and you can find it at any reputable auto parts store. You could also use a D8E #1200 stone and then finish with #2000 sandpaper. I promise you that your stones will be more pleasurable to use. :001_cool:
 

ouch

Stjynnkii membörd dummpsjterd
I thought the Shapton Pros had the worst feedback of any of their lines. The GlassStones are a big improvement overall, but in general if feedback is your top priority, Shapton isn't the best.
 

ouch

Stjynnkii membörd dummpsjterd
When I sharpen a knife on a Shapton 12K, I'm amazed at how much metal comes off from so fine a stone.
 
You solve this problem by changing how you lap them.

I own a mixture of glass and pro stones, and lap mine using the Shapton lapping powders. Never had any problem with lack of feedback from either type of stone, actually I have to be a bit careful with the 15k pro stone because it can be extremely grabby when the edge gets close to ready; one or two laps too far and I'll feel it suddenly stick and then it's too late, the edge is gone, broken by the hone.
 
I own a mixture of glass and pro stones, and lap mine using the Shapton lapping powders. Never had any problem with lack of feedback from either type of stone, actually I have to be a bit careful with the 15k pro stone because it can be extremely grabby when the edge gets close to ready; one or two laps too far and I'll feel it suddenly stick and then it's too late, the edge is gone, broken by the hone.
I love them just as they are but some people like to "feel" their hones.
 
Top Bottom