The Ogallala Bay Rum & Sandalwood is one of the best smelling aftershaves that I've used. It also lasts a long time. Does anyone else like it?
Last edited:
Ogallala Bay Rum & Sandalwood
- Thread starter KWilliams40
- Start date
It was my first Ogallala AS and it's the strongest and longest lasting of their AS and colognes. I have them all. The BR & Sandalwood AS is a little too strong for me, so I cut it with the regular Ogallala AS or cologne when I use it. I also like Ogallala shave soap and have several pucks on hand, including a puck of Bay Rum and Sandalwood that I'm looking forward to trying.
I enjoy it as well. The peppercorn variant is my favorite, but this is close.
My favorite Ogallala, but the Sage & Cedar is a close second.
Love their aftershaves.
I really like the Ogallala Sandlewood but I have to say that the Lime and Peppercorn is my favorite of the two. I have the sage and cedar but although it smells good as a scent, I am not quite sold as an aftershave. Maybe an air freshener. Somehow I don't think a man should smell like a closet! 
That's what it reminds me of.
I'm still really hooked on straight bay rum although for some reason Lime seems to really go well with bay rum.
That's what it reminds me of.
I'm still really hooked on straight bay rum although for some reason Lime seems to really go well with bay rum.
I got the sampler and love all of them. For me the scent does not last long enough but I will be getting the colognes and adding a little to the AS to help that out.
yeah it is a great as.. now that its spring in find myself using the limes and peppercorn more.
I loved it, but I am slightly allergic to it, so had to get rid of my OBR. 
Lime and peppercorn was my (and SWMBOs) favorite.
Lime and peppercorn was my (and SWMBOs) favorite.
Love this Ogallala aftershave. Great scent combo. I think best in cool weather. A rare item for which I get female comments, "What's that great smell?!"
Here it is paired with a sample of Mike's Bay Rum soap. I only wish it got used more often in my rotation.
Here it is paired with a sample of Mike's Bay Rum soap. I only wish it got used more often in my rotation.
I love Ogallala bay rum. I just splashed with it recently. It has the best smell. I may try the Lime and Peppercorns next. Love this stuff!
Kirk
Kirk
I just finished shaving about 15 minutes ago and Ogallala Lime and Peppercorn was my aftershave. Great scent but I only wish it lasted longer. I have no idea what peppercorn smells like but the lime and Bay Rum go together perfectly.
This scent is cursed for me.
I'm one of the ones that was not a fan of the Sandalwood and Bay Rum.
But the funny thing is that is severely angered SWMBO. Quite literally, a whiff of this scent changed her mood instantly.
Needless to say, I needed to get it out of the Den.
I arranged a trade with fellow member ¢orey. I packaged it up in a box and then in a padded envelope and printed my postage online thinking it could go as a first class parcel. Well, a week later they returned my package saying it could not be first class do to its irregular size.
So I went to the PO and shipped it via priority mail to poor ¢orey who had been waiting. So that should have been that. I wish. 10 days later, this again came back to me in the mail.
Despite being wrapped in bubble wrap. In a box that was wrapped in bubble wrap. Then in a padded envelope - they somehow managed to break it and it became a HAZMAT issue. Great. The best part is they say "return to sender for repackage." Hah - what am I going to do - repackage broken glass? Idiots.
So I ended up ordering ¢orey a bottle and having it shipped directly from WCS.
This was the most expensive AS I have ever tried as a result. I wasn't thrilled with the scent and it made my wife angry.
Keep this jazz away from me!!!
I'm one of the ones that was not a fan of the Sandalwood and Bay Rum.
But the funny thing is that is severely angered SWMBO. Quite literally, a whiff of this scent changed her mood instantly.
Needless to say, I needed to get it out of the Den.
I arranged a trade with fellow member ¢orey. I packaged it up in a box and then in a padded envelope and printed my postage online thinking it could go as a first class parcel. Well, a week later they returned my package saying it could not be first class do to its irregular size.
So I went to the PO and shipped it via priority mail to poor ¢orey who had been waiting. So that should have been that. I wish. 10 days later, this again came back to me in the mail.
Despite being wrapped in bubble wrap. In a box that was wrapped in bubble wrap. Then in a padded envelope - they somehow managed to break it and it became a HAZMAT issue. Great. The best part is they say "return to sender for repackage." Hah - what am I going to do - repackage broken glass? Idiots.
So I ended up ordering ¢orey a bottle and having it shipped directly from WCS.
This was the most expensive AS I have ever tried as a result. I wasn't thrilled with the scent and it made my wife angry.
Keep this jazz away from me!!!
