I only have the aftershave, and there's a good chance the soap isn't identical (I know with Plunder he seems to have made the two scents complimentary rather than perfectly matching)
At it's core it's a classic male bergamot and wood scent, with the vetiver adding a bit of dirt and the eucalyptus adding a bit of freshness. Very well balanced, all the notes are noticeable but none dominate. It's not, for example, going to be replacing Proraso Green in my cabinet any time soon.
Cooling lasts noticeably longer than menthol but isn't crazy strength.
Overall very pleased with it
