Next "Puck" Soap?

[SteveWY]

I am looking for something new to try in a puck style soap. I have been searching the shaving soap form and often see a variety or recommendations for soaps that are tub or soft soaps. Or people will recommend a soap that can be grated, mashed or melted into a mug. I get all that but I am looking for the drop-in convenience of a true puck or round of hard soap. (I have Cella and a couple shave sticks)

I have tried and still use Williams (I know), VDH Deluxe, and Colonel Conk. I'm still loving the value, availability and overall quality of VDH and will continue keeping that on hand. But variety is the spice of life! So, I'm looking for some suggestions to feed my SSAD with a different soap puck.

So, what is a "Must Try" hard soap?

 

[Duckster]

...So, what is a "Must Try" hard soap?

Tabac

 

[cryhavoc]

Mitchells Wool Fat

 

[7 O Menthol]

Since this is limited specifically to puck form, I vote for a puck from Calani! They offer some intoxicating scents and definitely bring great performance.

http://www.royalshave.com/p/422-029/calani-shaving-soap.html

 

[trick420]

Mitchell's Wool Fat all the way...

 

[petr]

AOS. Spring for the wood bowl.

 

[petr]

Since this is limited specifically to puck form, I vote for a puck from Calani! They offer some intoxicating scents and definitely bring great performance.

http://www.royalshave.com/p/422-029/calani-shaving-soap.html

+1. This man has discriminating taste.

 

[Optometrist]

MWF or D.R. Harris

 

[Rivguy]

You can't go wrong with some of the fine tried and true classics like MWF, D. R. Harris, Tabac and TOBS Lavender or Sandalwood. They are all excellent performers that will always have a place in my den and in the dens of many others. Yes, there are many soaps from which to choose and you will get many suggestions but I would recommend trying a classic such as listed above.

Regards,

Doug

 

[Niles]

MWF or D.R. Harris

+1 to these.

 

[Marco]

D.R. Harris is certainly a great choice.

 

[Neognosis]

eShave

 

[njpaddy]

Harris if you want the best or Tabac because everyone tries it sometime.

 

[deruitem]

Tabac

 

[Predict]

Tabac

 

[SteveWY]

Thank you Gents! Many good suggestions and I'm sure I will want to try most of not all of these!

 

[GreekGuy]

Since this is limited specifically to puck form, I vote for a puck from Calani! They offer some intoxicating scents and definitely bring great performance.

http://www.royalshave.com/p/422-029/calani-shaving-soap.html

Big +1

Although if you really like other soaps it may not be a good choice, as its ruined many of the heavy hitters for me (you won't want to use other soaps after trying Calani, its that good)

 

[VT_Hokie]

Haslinger

 

[stuart12dz]

I use Williams frequently and enjoy using it. If you're looking for something as an alternate, may I suggest any one of the Queen Charlotte Soaps or any of the soaps offered by Crabtree & Evelyn.

 

[gash]

Institut Karite is a French soap with Shea butter. It is remarkably slick and protective.