Looking for a recommendation.

[Mr_Spiffy]

I'm looking for a couple of new aftershaves to complement some of the soaps/creams that I have that really don't go well with the current AS products that I have. I'm hoping you guys might be able to recommend some products based on what I like and don't like, as well as the products that I have. I already have some clean, minty or aquatic AS products. I'm looking more for something with citrus, spice, maybe a warming feeling from the fragrance. Like mulled cider? Something to go more with the spicy/woodsy soaps and creams that I have, which you'll see from my items listed below. Even so, I'll list out likes/dislikes, and hopefully you guys might have some great suggestions!

So, here's what I have that needs a partner:

• Strop Shoppe Russian Tea
• Razorock Third Eye (sandalwood)
• Cella / P160 (almond)
• T&H 1805 (This may smell floral at first, but I catch hints of citrus in it when I lather it up.)
• TFS Lavanda

What types of fragrances I enjoy:

• Cool, clean and fresh, some might call these aquatic or water scents (I have one EdT that I really enjoy like this: Nautica Oceans.)
• Citrus (lemon, lime, orange, etc.)
• Spice
• Something warming, probably more suitable for colder months

What I typically avoid:

• "Musk"
• "Woodsy" or "grassy", though I may not avoid these entirely
• Anything with licorice scent
• Powdery, like Clubman.
• Floral
• Leather/tobacco
• I'm also not a huge fan of bay rum scents, but I've only smelled a couple. So I'm not really a good judge on these, yet.

If you guys have any suggestions on what to try, I'd appreciate it! I'm always looking to try something new.

I did order a three-pack from Captain's Choice, which has bay rum and hopefully a lime-scented aftershave, so I'm really looking forward to trying those out. I'm mostly in it for the lime, though. As I mentioned earlier, I'm not really huge into bay rum scents, at this point. But that could change, with the right fragrance.

 

[Mr_Spiffy]

Hoping I didn't come across too demanding or haughty here... was only hoping to provide details to help make recommendations.

Or perhaps my lists are a bit contradictory..? Or there's not much out there to fit what I'm looking for?

 

[Hirsute]

Ok, I'll bite. How about Musgo Citrus Spice, Florida Water, or Lucky Tiger?

 

[dillon_b12]

I recently got some Arko Citrus AS balm that has a nice orange/lemon scent to it.

 

[Mr_Spiffy]

Thanks guys!

I already have bottle of Lucky Tiger, and I really love it. The scent is pretty mild, though, and dissipates very quickly.

I also have a bottle of Clubman Eau de Portugal on the way, so hopefully that'll be nice.

I didn't even realize that Arko made AS...hmm. I'll have to look into that one. Sounds really nice!