Just picked up Old Spice Cologne Classic with a spray top as opposed to the stopper

[nycalling]

And it's pretty terrible. And I don't mean just compared to the Shulton Old Spice. I mean compared to the new Old Spice Cologne with the Red stopper. I don't have the olfactory knowledge to describe the differences, other than it's missing that sort of Old Spice 'vanilla' odor to my nose. I have an early 90's Old Spice cologne and aftershave set (with the grey stopper) and a pair of current Cologne/Aftershave set with the red stoppers, and this smells nothing like any of them.

It stinks, because I was looking forward to having an Old Spice Cologne with a spray top, but it's just not for me.

 

[Warpiper]

Ditto, I picked up some classic cologne and it's mild/faint. Nothing at all what I remembered OS smelling like and the scent doesn't last very long. Very disappointed, I was looking towards going back to olden days. I called OS yesterday and they told me that they have not changed their formula but I don't believe it.

 

[The Mick]

I just use a plastic spay bottle from Walmart