I see that MSC has a new soap base available. I have no experience with it. I love the frosted spearmint on hot summer days. It's a heavy menthol---not as heavy as Stirling but close. The Apricot Pie followed by Clubman Bay Rum splash is one of my favorite combinations for cold weather. MSC also produces 6 oz tubs compared to Stirling's 5.8 oz.I’m excited to try MSC against Stirling!