I have the Endymion, Sartorial, Blenheim Bouquet, English Fern and Elixir. My favourite is Elixir. Unfortunately, as mentioned by others, the scent doesn't last more than a couple of hours.
I just ordered this. I have been wanting to try different ones but didn't want to drop that kind of money on a bottle of cologne and not be sure I liked it.
http://www.smallflower.com/penhaligons/gentlemans-frangrance-collection-2013-5mleach-set-10071011
I rarely disagree with The Nid Hog or StylinLA, but I remain a big Blenheim Bouquet fan, and to disagree with TNH, but apparently not with SLA, am pretty much of a Pen's fan, at least as to its usual line of scents. I am not that crazy about the limited editions and similar that I have tried. I think English Fern is the best of its genre. Elixir is wonderful, although I rarely wear it these days. Sartorial is nice, although not any better than EF to me. I do not really like Endymion, but I do not like many gourmands. Racquets is nice enough if you can find it as an elegant barbershop scent. Opus is wonderful to me. I respect HB but I do not think I would wear it. LP No. 9 men's is not my cup of tea. LP No. 9 for women is better no matter what your gender. I am leaving some out. Whatever the one is that is similar to Acqua di Parma is good for the genre. The juniper one is nice.
Solid house with a lot of variety from my perspective. I do not think I have ever paid full retail for a bottle, but I can say that about virtually any fragrance I own.
That would be Castile. I agree, very nice scent. A little more floral than AdP..... especailly on the dry down, but very nice.
Ben