I have 17 Mama Bear's soaps that I rotate thru. I like having the variety of scents and I use the one that happens to appeal to me on that particular day.
If I hadn't won the B&B Smallflower.com raffle, I would probably only have one or two soaps and one or two creams in rotation. I just don't like a lot of clutter and have this thing about finishing products. But thanks to the raffle I have an abundance of choices:
Penhaligons Blenheim Bouquet - Mondays only
Proraso Green Tub - Best Menthol
DR Harris Arlington
MWF
AoS Lemon SS - best of the bunch for efficacy IMHO
TGQ Desert Ironwood - my favorite soap scent
TGQ Leatherneck
TGQ Highlander
Col Conk Amber
Sir Irisch Moos Shave Stick - travel only
Being new I am still trying to rotate through the different creams I have on hand, but I think I will eventually settle on soaps mainly. I just seems like I get a better, longer lasting lather without hardly using any product. I'm currently rotating between Tabac (my favorite so far!) and the little blue Godrej shaving round for when I'm on the road (quite a bit lately).
Being a newbie to DE shaving I only hold one soap and two creams
Proraso with Aloe & Green Tea
Edwin Jagger Sandalwood Premium Shaving Cream (I'll be using this for travel)
Truefitt & Hill Ultimate Comfort Shaving Cream
On my wishlist is:
Mitchell's Wool Fat
Fitja shaving soap or cream (still undecided to scent)
Tabac
For me I use shave sticks a lot. I have Irisch Moos, Arko and I turned my Tabac into shave stick. I also use MWF a lot more now that I think I've figured it out.