This is great, I wish I'd seen it sooner but better late than never!
The purpose of the water is to soften/dissolve some of the top of the soap, making it easier to load. I wouldn't do this with creams (I am assuming tubs, not tubesI'm curious... should this technique of pouring water in the tub be used for a cream too? Or is this only for soaps? I have similar problems with my cream lather drying out, like what he described in part 1.
Been tempted to try Neutrogena Glycerin Translucent soap as a shave soap. Tried it this AM. Washed first with cool water and the Neutrogena, rinsed with luke warm water. Than rubbed the wet bar all over my stubble, took my wet brush to face lather and very quickly had a dense slick lather. Got a 3 pass shave, using a DE89 with Derby Blade, very little irritation. I had to be careful not to go over a spot more than once without reapplying lather. There was more than enough lather in my brush for all three passes. The lather was not as slick as the slickest I have used, Nivea Sensitive Cream. But it was a comfortable, inexpensive, and easy to use alternative to specialty soaps and creams. As always YMMV.
Welcome aboard, @philcatc ! Whether a newbie or a not-so-newbie, a periodic review of some of these older informative threads (and wiki entries) is a wonderful thing.As a newbie I found the pictures really helped me understand your points on what the lather should look like. I have only recently moved away from cartridges and have found getting a decent lather from my TOBS Sandalwood frustrating. I will use your advise for my next shave.
(Found post via ShaveWiki)