I've been using (all 4 shaves) the Burt's Bees AS Balm. Just ordered the Bay Rum sampler from Ogalla Bay Rum. Looking forward to trying something different!
I started with the Ogallala sampler and now have a drawer full of their products, including large bottles of the aftershaves, double strength cologne, shave soaps, mug, even air freshener. Their bay rum shave soap may just be my favorite shave soap and I've got a drawer full of far more expensive soaps.