I wouldn't say I'm a fan of MdC. I'm a fan of its lather though. Of the creams I've tried (the four I remember are T&H, Pro red, Palm Green, and Penhal, though there were a couple others awhile back), the only one that shows potential to approach that level of lather quality is the Pro Red. Face lathering with my Rooney Finest (my version of giving a soap/cream a massive handicap), the T&H showed quality, but I'd put it between AOS/Valobra and Tabac for maximum lather quality in my environment. Not bad, but below MdC and it's ilk. Pro Red showed a lot of promise in it's first shave... but I'm gonna give it a couple more shaves before I fully judge it. I'd say it was right around Tabac level on its first go though.
Geo F Trumpers Coconut Oil
TOBS Lemon and Lime
DR Harris Almond
In that order, even though I have others and continue to try different ones these are the ones I use the most.
T&H - performance fine across board, then personal pref for scent (for me Limes and Sandalwood); TOBS - Jermyn Street Penhaligon's - only tried sample (thanks Garry) of Blenheim Bouquet and loved it, so don't know how "soft" it presents in jar, but i do know that i want it; all of the "Pens" come in tube also, so must be pretty soft.
Thanks for posting and please keep them coming .
MdC is currently my favorite lathering medium , but I'm searching for a cream that shares the qualities of MdC .
The best cream I've used was Domenico Caraceni 1913 but it's been discontinued .
I understand that Xpec is made by the same company .
I also like NancyBoy Replenishing and T&H Ultimate Comfort .
Looking forward to trying Simpsons Luxury .
Some of the creams mentioned like Proraso Green/Red , Lanolizado (Top Secret) , and Penhaligon's share ingredients with Barbasol .
I'm sure they're very good creams but I rather not go there at the moment .
TOBS sandalwood (most TOBS as they all lather and perform almost the same but Sandalwood is My fave scent. They produce a thick cushiony protective lather with decent lubrication)
Musgo Real Original ( Refreshing Menthol and the combination of lanolin glycerin and coconut oil leaves my face feeling great)
GFT Coconut (super slick for effortless shaving and the formulation leaves skin with a soft and supple feel)