Classic YMMV.
That actually might not be a bad name for a cologne.
How would you describe possible differences in results?
"Classic YMMV. YMMV."
I love the stuff and my wife does too, but if you were expecting a pure Sandalwood, I am not surprised at the disappointment. From Basenotes:
Top Notes
Lavender, Bergamot, Clary Sage, Lemon .
Middle Notes
Geranium, Sandal, Basil, Cedarwood, Patchouli, Vetiver .
Base Notes
Treemoss, Amber, Musk, Opopanax, Labdanum, Tonka .
For me, the Patchouli is very pronounced and I suspect that is a big part of what's bothering the naysayers. I tried it and think it smells great, but YMMV! At least the admission price is low!
Dave
That's right. I also like the Lavender/Treemoss that I get when it goes on. As long as you go easy on the sprayer, I think it's great.