Does TOBS St. James cologne smell like the stick?

[slather]

I just got a TOBS St. James stick and I really like the smell. Does the cologne by the same name smell just like the stick?

I thought I wanted to get Mr. Taylors but now having smelled the St. James stick, I'm torn between the two colognes and can't afford both ...

Any way to get these 2 cologne samples before I buy a bottle?

 

[Cains Boy]

I'd like to know the answer to this as well. St. James was the first proper cream I ever used, and now that I'm a soap guy, I have the stick.

To the original question, I would add: "how is the longevity?"

 

[bnndx2]

I'm curious to know as well. How is the longevity? I am considering TOBS St James and GFT Spanish Leather, but after sampling the Spanish Leather, I'm not sure about its longevity. To me a cologne has to have longevity, otherwise, whats the point?