Having sampled their creams, I have difficulty telling much of a difference in scent among some of their creams (Mr Taylor, Eton College, Shaving Shop, and St. James). So deciding on 2 will be rather tough. How do you discern the differences in scent and which ones do you prefer?
Discerning the different TOBS scents
- Thread starter bnndx2
- Start date
Although I've never smelt any of those four except Eton College, I can tell you that the next thing on my list to buy is definatly Eton College. From what I hear it last incredibly long for a tub, and I really like the smell, it's very masculine, while not being too powerful.
If I do buy it, and really love the scent day after day using it, I'd most likely even pick up the cologne.
You could try the coffee grind trick if you're having trouble telling the differences in the scents. Smell one, than smell coffee grinds, smell the next!
HAGS
Chrislols
If I do buy it, and really love the scent day after day using it, I'd most likely even pick up the cologne.
You could try the coffee grind trick if you're having trouble telling the differences in the scents. Smell one, than smell coffee grinds, smell the next!
HAGS
Chrislols
I stay away from strong floral scents.
that being said, I like the Avacado for it's lather and moisture, but it seems to me that it's a little flowery smelling. That's just my nose, others might disagree. I'm a fan of the Eton College and Sandalwood.
that being said, I like the Avacado for it's lather and moisture, but it seems to me that it's a little flowery smelling. That's just my nose, others might disagree. I'm a fan of the Eton College and Sandalwood.
I can definitely tell the difference between Shaving Shop and Mr. Taylor's, but I can't exactly put my finger on what the difference is. Now Avocado, I don't think anyone can mistake that one. Great lather, but not my favorite scent.
Do you mean you detect a strong-but-similar scent from all four, or not much from any of them? I have a pretty marginal sense of smell, it turns out; so, I pick products more on what they can do for my shave, rather (sadly) than the scent.
- Thread starter
- #6
Eton College is wonderful - a clean, pleasant aroma. Sandalwood is great too - kind of a woodsy, earthy aroma. I also have Rose and Lavender - great floral scents. All four give rich, smooth lather. It comes down to personal choice. However, if it comes down to budget, I would do the Eton College and Sandalwool.Good stuff and will last a long time.
What do you mean if it comes down to budget? Aren't they all the same size?
- Thread starter
- #7
I can definitely tell the difference between Shaving Shop and Mr. Taylor's, but I can't exactly put my finger on what the difference is. Now Avocado, I don't think anyone can mistake that one. Great lather, but not my favorite scent.
I'm wondering if Shaving Shop and Sandalwood don't almost identical composition, with the Sandalwood having an extra fragrance ingredient or two?
I've only tried Eton College and WOW was I blown away with the lovely scent! Can't wait to get my hands on some Rose!
- Thread starter
- #9
Well they all tend to smell very similar in several groups. Eton College and Mr Taylor with Eton College having a stronger scent. St. James and Shaving Shop, with St. James having a stronger scent, and Sandalwood having similar soapy fragrances. and such. They aren't VERY distinct to my nose somehow.
after careful consideration, i think eton college may be the best tobs scent.
- Thread starter
- #12
Now the question becomes, Eton College or Mr. Taylor?
Excellent choice, but then you also have Sandalwood and Avocado...
This might help:
The Taylor Fragrance Range
1. Eton College Collection
Inspired by the tradition of Eton, England's premier college of royalty and the aristocracy, and especially formulated for its Gentlemen, this collection possesses a fresh invigorating fragrance combining sparkling citrus oils with rich woody undertones to enchant the senses of the young and the young at heart.
2. Mr Taylor Collection
For generations, discriminating gentlemen have selected this crisp and spicy fragrance in which Tarragon, Lavender and Incense combine with hints of Green Galbanum and Citrus for an elegant manly scent and a warm, woody drydown with traces of Cedar, Sandal, Patchouli and Musk.
3. Sandalwood Collection
From the mystic east, we take a complex rich woody blend of exotic sweet scented Sandalwood and Cedar, add Lavender and Rosemary with subtle floralcy and Jasmine and Rose, for a vivacious, enticing, confidently masculine bouquet.
4. St. James's Collection
A masculine, fougere with citrus ozonic top notes of Bergamot and Mandarin combined with crisp herbs. Heart notes utilise florals, fruits and spices on a base of Sandalwood, Amber, Patchouli and Musk.
5. Shaving Shop Collection (Maroon Range)
Revitalising fresh Citrus traces blend vigorously with the sophistication and ruggedness of precious Cedar and Oak woods. Add virile undertones of musks over a floor of Sage, Rosemary and Petitgrain for an alluring composition that stimulates the senses and excites the emotions.
6. Lavender
To the truly discerning gentleman, nothing surpasses the superior floral perfume of English Lavender, freshly picked at its peak from Norfolk Lavender, England's Lavender Farm, or the relaxing and soothing effect it imparts.
7. No.74 Original
A floral cologne fragrance with top notes of orange, bergamot and lemon with a background of lilac, jasmine, rose and sweet musk.
8. No.74 Victorian Lime
Citrus, lime, woody, fuschia
9. Jermyn Street Collection for Sensitive Skin
A modern fresh fougere fragrance with bergamot, lemon, lime and lavender supported by a heart of geranium, neroli and amber resting on a substantive base of musk, patchouli and vanilla.
From:
http://www.tayloroldbondst.co.uk/hintstips.html
The Taylor Fragrance Range
1. Eton College Collection
Inspired by the tradition of Eton, England's premier college of royalty and the aristocracy, and especially formulated for its Gentlemen, this collection possesses a fresh invigorating fragrance combining sparkling citrus oils with rich woody undertones to enchant the senses of the young and the young at heart.
2. Mr Taylor Collection
For generations, discriminating gentlemen have selected this crisp and spicy fragrance in which Tarragon, Lavender and Incense combine with hints of Green Galbanum and Citrus for an elegant manly scent and a warm, woody drydown with traces of Cedar, Sandal, Patchouli and Musk.
3. Sandalwood Collection
From the mystic east, we take a complex rich woody blend of exotic sweet scented Sandalwood and Cedar, add Lavender and Rosemary with subtle floralcy and Jasmine and Rose, for a vivacious, enticing, confidently masculine bouquet.
4. St. James's Collection
A masculine, fougere with citrus ozonic top notes of Bergamot and Mandarin combined with crisp herbs. Heart notes utilise florals, fruits and spices on a base of Sandalwood, Amber, Patchouli and Musk.
5. Shaving Shop Collection (Maroon Range)
Revitalising fresh Citrus traces blend vigorously with the sophistication and ruggedness of precious Cedar and Oak woods. Add virile undertones of musks over a floor of Sage, Rosemary and Petitgrain for an alluring composition that stimulates the senses and excites the emotions.
6. Lavender
To the truly discerning gentleman, nothing surpasses the superior floral perfume of English Lavender, freshly picked at its peak from Norfolk Lavender, England's Lavender Farm, or the relaxing and soothing effect it imparts.
7. No.74 Original
A floral cologne fragrance with top notes of orange, bergamot and lemon with a background of lilac, jasmine, rose and sweet musk.
8. No.74 Victorian Lime
Citrus, lime, woody, fuschia
9. Jermyn Street Collection for Sensitive Skin
A modern fresh fougere fragrance with bergamot, lemon, lime and lavender supported by a heart of geranium, neroli and amber resting on a substantive base of musk, patchouli and vanilla.
From:
http://www.tayloroldbondst.co.uk/hintstips.html
