Sounds like you like have some winners!
Critique my soap list
- Thread starter Tester28
- Start date
B&M
Le Grand Chypre
Cologne Russe
Cheshire
Seville
Cool Reserve
Whole Kaw
Fern Concerto Menthol (donkey milk/tallow)
Fougere Parfaite (Vegan base)
Ariana & Evans
L'Orange Vert
Menthol
Margaritas in the Attic
Snakebite
Cryogen
I couldn't critique cause it is what you like and I respect that, but I'll pretend it's my list, if it would help.
I try to avoid anything menthol so I'd drop those from my list. I find the cold sensation on my skin tends to make me a little careless with my technique.
I haven't tried A&E, so I might include that to satisfy my curiosity.
I'd drop WK Vegan and opt for their tallow buffalo base. Fougere Bouquete is my favorite scent from WK.
I like all those B&M soaps, but Cool Reserve is probably my least favorite. Floid blue scent is pretty ubiquitous and the Glissant base worked better for me than Reserve. However, I would drop them all for the Excelsior base if available.
Le Grand Chypre
Cologne Russe
Cheshire
Seville
Cool Reserve
Whole Kaw
Fern Concerto Menthol (donkey milk/tallow)
Fougere Parfaite (Vegan base)
Ariana & Evans
L'Orange Vert
Menthol
Margaritas in the Attic
Snakebite
Cryogen
I couldn't critique cause it is what you like and I respect that, but I'll pretend it's my list, if it would help.
I try to avoid anything menthol so I'd drop those from my list. I find the cold sensation on my skin tends to make me a little careless with my technique.
I haven't tried A&E, so I might include that to satisfy my curiosity.
I'd drop WK Vegan and opt for their tallow buffalo base. Fougere Bouquete is my favorite scent from WK.
I like all those B&M soaps, but Cool Reserve is probably my least favorite. Floid blue scent is pretty ubiquitous and the Glissant base worked better for me than Reserve. However, I would drop them all for the Excelsior base if available.
- Thread starter
- #43
Well, the snakebite had a strong menthol smell which was eye watering if you leaned
into the puck. But it is such an awkward size it wouldn't fit into any container I have.
So I jammed it into the underside of the top lid of a Mitchell Wool Fat container....where
it fits perfectly...the only problem was it had to be left exposed.
Now the strong menthol smell has dissipated and don't even feel it much on the face.
Grrrrr.....nice slick soap still, albeit a snake with no bite.
into the puck. But it is such an awkward size it wouldn't fit into any container I have.
So I jammed it into the underside of the top lid of a Mitchell Wool Fat container....where
it fits perfectly...the only problem was it had to be left exposed.
Now the strong menthol smell has dissipated and don't even feel it much on the face.
Grrrrr.....nice slick soap still, albeit a snake with no bite.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Article
