I've never tried the superhold but the green one works well for me at an outstanding price for a large tub. I saw axe upped their price to $9 a jar and found clubman is much cheaper per unit. The superhold will be on my next order.
I have always used Clubman hair gel. I have never had an issue with flaking. It doesn't even feel like you are using hair gel. And the scent, well that does it for me.
I also enjoy the regular green tub very much. For me, it holds very well, I can't see myself needing anymore hold. It also washes out very easily and has a light barbershop scent that isn't overpowering at all and washes it completely at the end of the day. The only thing I don't like is that it's not re-combable, but the hold is so good that I never find myself needing to recomb my hair so I guess I really don't have any complaints about it. Contrary to Brylcreem and Groom and Clean, it does "set" and "harden" I don't know if that matters to you