Captain's Choice new release - can you I.D. it?

[Captain Pre-Capsize]

I'll be candid and say it is going to take a bit more time before the formula is ready to have free sample sent out, maybe a week or two. For now I thought it might be fun to see who can guess the scent I have been working on. If I were smart I would have just been a mime and keep my mouth shut until it is actually ready but NOOOO, I had to get a jump on matters! It hasn't been easy and it STILL isn't easy but we are getting there, rest assured.

Well, there you have it. The paragraph above contains enough information for you to guess the scent of the new Captain's Choice aftershave. Go ahead, reread it and look for a clue in there somewhere as to the soon-to-be forthcoming brand new aftershave. What will it be? There is BAY RUM, the second is CAT O' NINE TAILS and the third... ???

Take a guess and let's see how good you are!

 

[Squidma]

I would have just been a mime...

Just happens to rhyme with LIME. Therefore I am going with Bay Rum with Lime.

 

[mheusler]

Hmmm Cat O Nine Tails is capitalized as is bay rum. As is Nooo and Still. I think it's a word scramble of noooo and still. You could make lotion out of that scramble. Perhaps a balm?

Max.

 

[deruitem]

I also think it will have lime!

 

[Gam]

Yep,lime

 

[lowjax]

Hmm, on one hand, lime is a good guess, but that's already been taken.

So, to go in a completely other direction, my guess is that it will be an alcohol free version (NOOOO STILL).

 

[Shave_Rat]

Lime would be awesome! I've been mixing the orig Capt Choice with some lime bay rum from another popular brand in a 3:1 ratio or so already for several months now and nicknamed it Anti-Scurvy. I'll guess (and hope) it's lime as well.

 

[Squidma]

Hmm, on one hand, lime is a good guess, but that's already been taken.

So, to go in a completely other direction, my guess is that it will be an alcohol free version (NOOOO STILL).

I think I might like this guess better than lime...

 

[mheusler]

Hmm, on one hand, lime is a good guess, but that's already been taken.

So, to go in a completely other direction, my guess is that it will be an alcohol free version (NOOOO STILL).

i think you nailed it.

 

[chado006]

...alcohol free version (NOOOO STILL).

Exactly what I was thinking but you beat me to it!

 

[blzrfn]

I'm going to say it is a mentholated, bay rum scented balm, that way you have a very diverse product line that has just about everybody (that likes bay rum as much as I do) covered.

 

[Riff Raff]

I am jumping on the bandwagon and going with lime as well. Limes have a long history of all things nautical. It just seems logical that the next Captain's Choice would be Lime! And that would be awesome! Seeing as I am an old shellback from way back!

 

[Mick]

Alcohol free Key Lime

hey... had to be a little different to play the game, didn't I?

 

[Head Rigger]

Alcohol free Key Lime

+1 I'd really like to see that one!

 

[Gordy2]

On an earlier post I mentioned lime, I think I'll stick with it.

 

[TheVez2]

I'll be candid and say...

I think candid... Candy is the clue. Must be something sweet. I'm guessing Tropical Coconut.

 

[Mr5x5]

Alcohol free

 

[godsantagonist]

well, i didn't know alcohol-free was a "scent", but I've been wrong before. i get "lion stool" as an anagram. i can only imagine what that smells like sitting in the hot sun all day, and don't think it would make a good scent.

 

[jay67212]

I say whisky. Lime. Whisky lime. Lime whisky. Whiskey. Heck, I could do this all day!

 

[ShavingSrgn]

I hate to jump on the bandwagon, but I'm thinking lime as well.