So my wife has a rather sensitive sense of smell and has only approved of about 3 (and only actually likes 1) of the at least 12 aftershaves I've tried. I recently bought some clubman citrus musk but before today I think she's only got a brief whiff of it once as I was leaving for work. The citrus smell (for me) is a bit strong at first but once it mellows a bit I like it a lot--more every time I wear it, actually. Today she got up and was getting into the shower right after I had put some on and I got a "what's that smell? I like it." I was shocked.