This is my recommendation:
Thayers gets lots of use on the tube by shavers & no alcohol added.
I'm curious about the tea tree oil. I have some, but I've never tried it in aftershave. Does the odor linger long, or does it go away quickly?
Be careful with tea tree oil. Keep it away from your eyes and applying it full strength may cause irritation and swelling.
It seems to have anti-fungal and antibacterial properties. It can be drying and/or irritating if used in concentrated form....I feel like the tea tree oil has helped.
And thank you for the warm welcome!