Are any of these balms notably better/worse than the others?

[CzechCzar]

On my shortlist to (re)buy I have the following balms:

• Hawkins and Brimble - currently my go-to
• PAA Mysterium Serum
• Cella Bio
• La Toja regular/sensitive
• Speick
• Lather & Wood
• Brickell
• Marlowe

I am at the point where I am sick of buying stuff. Do any of these beat out Hawkins & Brimble? Do any of them fail to do so?

Please let me know!!

 

[Marco]

Sir, I do not know most of the balms you have listed above, hence cannot give any comment on them. But, during my 27 years of wet shaving, I have tested hundreds of them. Nothing for me is comparable to Hawkins & Brimble, my undisputed #1 pick.