i really like the thick QED ASBs like bay rum and lime, and am disappointed that charles will no longer offer them.
does anyone have suggestions for products that are similar?
does anyone have suggestions for products that are similar?
Alternatives to QED ASBs?
- Thread starter tm3
- Start date
That's a shame 
Charles made some of the best ASBs I've tried.
Maybe give Brut balm a try?
Charles made some of the best ASBs I've tried.Maybe give Brut balm a try?
Not *quite* as thick, but the balms from SCS are certainly worth a look. Similar price range, not quite as strongly scented, but close, and nicely protective. I have her "Dagger" scented balm, and find that it works well for me on cold/dry days (I'm a splash guy otherwise). Proraso balm is great in the protection department, too, but if it's thickness you want, you'll be disappointed. The "Signature" balm from Gentlemen's Best would also be a good option -- fantastic scent, and again, nicely protective.
- Thread starter
- #4
thanks for the suggestions -- i've ordered some SCS samples.
the problem with trying out a lot of this stuff is lack of sample size availability, shipping costs, etc.
the problem with trying out a lot of this stuff is lack of sample size availability, shipping costs, etc.
Wesley & Scott from www.ShavingEssentials.biz
- Thread starter
- #6
they are not showing on their site any more.
plus while i love the clove/peppermint, the W&S is thinner than i prefer.
i just picked up some lime EO and Nivea for a DIY try. if i could figure out how to thicken it up i would have a winner.
Castle-Forbes ASB's are rich, very lush. Magnificent. If you can find them, indulge yourself. Recommended.
-- John Gehman
-- John Gehman
+1 for SCS. Try the Bulgarian Rose.
I got a sample of the "spiced rum" ASB from Krissy at Prairie Creations. It's nice and goopy, and moisturizes like the dickens.
If you want to try something similar to QED I would recommend Olivia's ASB.
http://www.olivia-seife.de/neu/public/index.php
She has both a summer and winter version and now she will scent them for you. I have not tried the summer but the winter is very moisturizing.
http://www.olivia-seife.de/neu/public/index.php
She has both a summer and winter version and now she will scent them for you. I have not tried the summer but the winter is very moisturizing.
Prairie Creations balm is pretty thick. I can't directly compare it to QED's as I never tried Charles' AS. The Prairie Creations AS absorbs quickly and works well. Check Krissy's site to see if she offers samples.
- Thread starter
- #12
i got some SCS samples. definitely a couple of winners there, but none as thick as i would like. will keep on the hunt ...
