The product is very good. I bought that product in 2012 and now, in 2015, 3 years later, the scent is gone.
The manufacturer reformulate the scent. This is a review on the old scent. Apparently, the performance is the same.
I gave a neutral 5 as the original scent was mild and nice (green scent) but now it's all gone.
The product is very soft, it requires a holder or something to wrap the product otherwise it's border line unsuable. I used a palmolive shave stick holder to use this product. It was maybe 1mm wider than palmolive.
The lather was easy to make, the product being soft, is easy to spread on the whiskers. I did not experience a bad lather with this one.
Overall, I would recommend this product if you can find it.