Of the soaps listed as options I’ve only used Stirling and B&M. Both are great soaps and I’d have trouble deciding which one has the better base. Stirling would be my choice for scents though. A couple that aren’t listed that I find to be really good are Speick stick and Cella. Between Speick and Cella I’d say Cella has the better richness but it would have to be an everyday usage soap compared to Speick