Revised version - opinions sought!

[Captain Pre-Capsize]

Tell me what you think! I wanted to get feedback from you all on our brushes. We have an artisan that has made them for many years to my design. Both shape and color. They have proven to be steady sellers from day one. Our current offering is on the right. Secure grip, nautical color to the resin - a swirling blend of blue and bronze.

I had him make up one this shape in a different color resin, call it abalone. It favors the shell of the same color. I had him create a new shape for us on his lathe. In the hand it feels chunkier to me in a good way, fingers nestle right in there.

What do you think of:

1. Color
2. Shape

Be candid, you aren't going to hurt any feelings here. Mainly I had him create this one-off for feedback both good and bad. Both of these have the synthetic knot and we have them available in Silvertip as well but are presently out of stock.

And there is an idea: What if silver tip were only available in this new color and shape handle. Then the synthetic remains as it is. Or maybe you can come up with another version? Would love to hear what you all think!

~ The Captain

 

[jaro 101969]

@Captain Pre-Capsize is the loft different on the one on the left ??

 

[Phoenixkh]

I’ve seen some very expensive brushes with handles similar to the one on the right. I’ve always admired the design. I’m more of a two-band silvertip myself as I like a bit of gentle scrub.

 

[Captain Pre-Capsize]

@Captain Pre-Capsize is the loft different on the one on the left ??

The loft is the same. The handle on the left is a bit taller, that may be what you are seeing.

 

[BanjoCowboyMartaTobes]

I like them both and to nitpick, I like the thickness of the left, the style of the right. That abalone would be epic if stirred more, as is the coloring on the right then is preferable. Appreciate you Captain so much. It’s very cool you let us join you a bit in this adventure!

 

[ChriWilson]

Digging the color and shape of the abalone brush on the left.
I prefer natural over synthetic, with exception to travel.

Looks great Scott !

 

[Lightcs1776]

I like the thinner handle on the right. I have what I assume are average hands. The one on the right just looks like it would be more comfortable to hold. I like having the option of both though.

 

[Phoenixkh]

I’ve seen some very expensive brushes with handles similar to the one on the right. I’ve always admired the design. I’m more of a two-band silvertip myself as I like a bit of gentle scrub.

I see I’m confused once again. I’m colorblind, as some might recall. I thought the abalone was on the right. I’m home from work now and took a closer look (and read). I do like the simple design of the new proposed brush on the left as well.

An aside: a few of us have been looking for something special for our Athenas: a clear razor stand. I don’t know if your handle guy and you would be interested in a small project like that or not. It might not be worth the investment for you but I thought I’d mention it. My own idea for the shape would be a Persian Jar design, clear so its beautiful handle would be visible.

 

[Multum in parvo]

I have one of your Silvertips and the handle feels perfect for me. The new handle looks a bit clunky but might feel good in hand.

I was contemplating Abalone a while ago for a Shavemac brush but somehow it didn’t fit for me. Having something brighter and nautical in your line up is a good move though.

What about Beachcomber

Or Copper Canyon to go with your bowls

 

[OldSaw]

The one on the left is my preference. Simple and easy to grip.

I have a brush with a handle like the one on the right and I almost never use it even though I want to. It’s the grip that keeps me from using it. Maybe because the first joint of my thumb bends back so far, I just can’t get a good comfortable grip on that thing and it annoys me.

 

[Multum in parvo]

Come to think about it the left one looks like an upside down Eagle

 

[hairless wonder]

I'm the wrong person to comment on aesthetics, but I do like the classic look of the one on the right. I especially like how the handle tapers to allow the brush to hang better from brush stands, which should allow the brush to dry better (this may be more of an issue with natural hairs, like silvertip, though).

I've had brushes with thick handles; drying them was difficult. I really didn't want to dry them upside down, as that could lead to mold in the knot.

 

[borwish]

I prefer the looks of the one on the right for both color and shape.

 

[bartje-p]

I prefer the shape of the right one! I think the left one is too bulky looking, in Dutch we say "lomp". The one on the right looks more refined with nicer details.

 

[slimshavy]

I like the color of the one on the right, as it's more classic metallic theme, but I respect the one on the left, as it could be more of a hippie vibe. I don't think the shape of the one on the left works for the color, though. It's frumpy instead of playful, creating an undesirable contrast with the color pattern.
I like the shape of the one on the right. For looks and functionality both, I'd suggest moving the ring up the handle so the collar is less thick and the grip part of it is a little wider. That would make holding it more comfortable.

 

[lancre]

I prefer the handle on the right for both shape and color. If I were to purchase one, it would be with a natural hair knot.

 

[dotKomo]

I prefer the brush on the right - both color and shape.

 

[ButterfaceX]

The Rights have it for me.
Sync's use for vegan soaps.
Boar for the occasional tallow.
22/24 mm
Don't know anything about the knots ..
Like the colors but think a more contrasting colors mixed might pop more...

BFX

The Captain Rocks!

 

[Guido75]

I prefer the design of the right one. Both are awesome in their color design as well.

Personally, I am a fan of synthetic knots in terms of your question to the knot.

 

[Star_Wahl_Clipper_Treker]

I too prefer the brush who's a shining star to the right, and strait on to lathering. I agree with others, it's more refined, and might go really well with your Obsidian bowls.