Honing stroke, X or Straight shot?

Discussion in 'Hones/Honing' started by Monkeyboy, Jun 1, 2008.

When using a honing stone wide enough to accommodate a razor's full edge, you:

  1. Use the X-stroke

  2. Run straight along the stone

Multiple votes are allowed.
Results are only viewable after voting.
  1. When using a honing stone wide enough to accommodate the full razor's edge, do you use the X-pattern stroke or just run length-wise?
     
  2. I always use an X-Pattern regardless of the stone width.
     
  3. A tough question to answer. You'll find both opinions. Many will tell you you need to use the X all the time and many will tell you to just lead with the heel a tad and go straight up the hone and you'll be OK. I use both methods and find they work equally well however I gravitate towards the X mostly because most of my hones are narrow so I'm used to doing it that way. You just have to be a bit more careful if you go straight up the hone because you can more uneven wear.

    Of course this gravitates into the next issue of whether you hone with one hand or two.
     
  4. I alternate and do both during a honing session so I guess I won't be able to answer the poll since there's no option for 'both'.
     
  5. Always X; except when working on a smiling or frowning edge.
     
  6. always use an X pattern,it puts the scratches at a 45 degree angle on the bevel
     
  7. I think this is a very individulized thing.

    I've tried both methods and personnaly get much better results going straight up and back instead of the X pattern. I have one razor that was the exception as the spine had some very uneven honewear.

    In the end the correct answer is which ever one works best for you.

    -80s
     
  8. Kind of new at this but always an X so far.
     
  9. Straight up and down when setting a bevel on the Shapton 1.5 and 5 K, otherwise ususally an X.
     
  10. professorchaos

    professorchaos Moderator Emeritus

    X, always.
     
  11. Limey

    Limey Moderator Emeritus

    The X works for me!
     
  12. X pattern, especially since all the razors I have are restored ebay junkers. You can work around anything but the worst warpage and/or smiles with an X pattn...just try that with straight passes!
     

Share This Page