I just purchased Osage Rub. I don't know if it is the menthol but the Osage and my Generic Skin Bracer but once it dries my face feels awesome. Not dry, sticky, or greasy. Just perfect and also very smooth. The Skin bracer and the Osage are the only splashes that I own that cool my face. The Generic Aqua Velva doesn't cool my face. Anyone else experience this? Here are my A/S Splashes and how they feel. Generic Aqua Velva: Leaves face slightly greasy/shiny once it drys. Master Topaz: Face is neither dry or greasy. Has a bit of shine and face not smooth. Speick: Leaves face slightly moisturized but not greasy. Generic Skin Bracer: Leaves skin smooth and not greasy or dry. Osage Rub: Leaves skin smooth and not greasy or dry.