What is the best clubman soap dupe?

[BobbyBacala]

I'm looking for a artisan soap that smells like clubman penaud what is the best dupe out there?

 

[rockviper]

Give this a shot...

 

[JimL911]

Fine Clubhouse Shaving Soap

Experience the classic charm of Clubman Shave Soap and Clubman Pinaud Shave Soap at Fine Accoutrements. Elevate your shave today! Shop now!

fineaccoutrements.com

 

[shavetrooper]

Don't forget about PAA's Clubguy. It's on my Wish List to get soon!

 

[JimL911]

Don't forget about PAA's Clubguy.

Skip it.

 

[shavetrooper]

Skip it.

Why?

 

[Big Jim]

Fine's Clubhouse soap is a good match for Clubman aftershave although it is stronger than the after shave. Clubman soap doesn't resemble the after shave at all. It is more like their vanilla aftershave.

 

[JimL911]

Why?

Fine's Clubhouse soap is a good match for Clubman aftershave

Almost a dead ringer.
Clubguy is an OK soap, but the scent isn't close to Clubman.