What are your favorite Mystic Waters scents?

[Demaskee]

I really like they way my face feels after I shave with MW. I currently have Cedar & Sage and Bay Rum. I LOVE the Cedar & Sage, the Bay Rum is just ok to me. It smells good in the tub, but once I lather it, it just smells like soap. Performance is still great though.

Anyhow, I'm looking to get a few more pucks and figured I would use the gents on here to help me decide which scents I should get.

What say you?

 

[shavefan]

I only have the Bay rum & unscented so I can't help too much. As far as bay rums I've tried this one isn't too bad (not overly clovey). I love the performance if the unscented and sometimes add some shave cream to create a Superlather in the flavor of my choice.

 

[evnpar]

Sandalwood Rose (Ooh LaLa!!!), Mysore Sandalwood, Rosalimone, and Sardinian Honey. Did I forget to mention Viola di Bosco?

 

[Darkbulb]

Can't comment much on the scents as I only have the unscented one...but that one does smell nice - no odd tallowy/clay'y/meaty/odd smells, just very clean and fresh.
Love it.

 

[bosseb]

I'm having trouble describing scents because of my lack of routine and the fact that English is my third language.

I have six soaps from Michelle and during the warm period my favorite was Prospect Creek because of the cooling effect. Now when the weather is turning cooler I have the Marrakesh as a favorite just ahead of the Lily of the Valley.

I think that Michelle's soaps are very nicely scented with an intriguing and complex mix of scents. The thing with these soaps is not the scents but the stellar performance for me. I was very surprised to find that these soaps deliver on par with the best IMHO.

 

[kingfisher]

She has a lot of nice scents.

Right now if I had to choose just one it would be Rosalimone. It's awesome.

 

[Rocinante]

On scent alone? Maestrale is my favorite.

The new "Jeff's Lavender" is great too, very straightforward lavender scent.

On the softer floral side I like Lily of the Valley and Viola di Bosco.

 

[bassopotamus]

I've only used Adirondack Jack, but it is among my absolute favorite scents.

 

[volleymh9]

Mysore Sandalwood is my favorite scent with honarble mentions to Orange Vanilla, Lemon Verbana, and Viola de Bosco

 

[Haggises]

For me, Bay Rum then Maestrale.

Loking forward to some others next year.

 

[TheVez2]

Here are my favorite MW scents:
#1 - Lily of the Valley
#2 - Cedar & Sage
#3 - Rosalimone
#4 - Lavender Lime

 

[jzuzphreek]

So this thread doesn't help me make a decision... at all!

Q:What is your favorite scent?
A: Lists which total up to every scent available.

 

[shaverjoe]

Maestrale by a wide margin

 

[dvjohnso]

Marrakesh by far

 

[MJB1]

Adirondack Jack, unfortunately it made a better shower soap than shave soap...

 

[shevek]

Cedar and Sage, followed by Viola di Bosco

 

[Demaskee]

With all due respect to Michelle, she's going to have to start making some crappy scents. I go to her website and am overwhelmed by the awesome selection. I come to this site and appeal to you fine gents only to be told in so many words, to basically to buy every one of them.

Maybe I should have asked which ones you don't like

 

[Haggises]

OK. let's try descriptions (cuz I don't know what most of those smell like either)

Maestrale - a fragrance that is both sweet and savory, quite rich without overpowering. Sweet peppermint lies on top of a savory bed of lavender and rosemary. Slightly cooling, but no menthol blast.

Coconut Lime Verbena - like a lemon/lime popsicle. Don't get much coconut under the citrus. Citrus is not strong or overly sharp like a straight Lime.

 

[f86sabjf]

Coconut is nice and light
Orange and vanilla is my favorite


I would like to see a piña colada smell. Pineapple and coconut with a light rum background

 

[Jefebadskin]

Adirondack Jack is wonderful. Viola di Bosco, Sandalwood Rose right after. I'm partial to Jeff's Lavender so I'll just say I like it too.