Hi Max,
Interesting, I have used Rooneys from multiple sources (including Vintageblades), and have never experienced the Super or Silvertip to have scratchy tips. You can get a good scrubbing going due to the firmness, but I've never noticed the tips themselves to be scratchy at all, and I'm very sensitive to it.
Now the Finest hair can be a bit scritchy for sure.
The SR3118 was much softer feeling in terms of backbone, that I will agree with. The Rooney Supers/Silvertips I have used had very soft tips, but still good backbone/density.
Regards.
J
+1 on the description of the Rooney Silver/Super hair. My #1 large has very soft tips with resilant shafts - a great combination.
In my view, the Rooneys in the Silver/Super hair are some of the best values out there in terms of a brush with soft tips/good backbone and very dense knots.