Gentlemen.
I am a new smoker going on 5 months and on the hunt for a great tobacco, but it's getting a little out of control the amount of tobacco I am starting to collect and not liking. I need your recommendation on a tobacco that is satisfying and tastes great.
At the moment I enjoy Squadron leader which to me is mild and tasty, ( but missing something, don't know what it is though) I also like McClellan Wilderness a Very satisfying smoke but slightly over the top in smoke flavors.
What I'm looking for would be between Squadron leader and Wilderness....if that is possible. I know the tobacco conisuers on here can figure it out.
Tobacco I've tried and won't buy again, I would reconsider on the best brown (great tobacco).
Larry's blend. To light in flavour.
Samuel Gawith Best brown Flake. Great tobacco but the nicotine is to much.
Frog Morton. Mild, something is missing with this tobacco.
Chelsea morning. Not for me can't remember why, it's been a while since I've tried it - lets just say not a memorable smoke.
Solani Silver label 660. Good smoke, not to smooth not a rounded smoke for me.
Captain Earle's Honor blend. Good smoke still a little edgy not rounded tobacco flavour.
Esotrica Dorchester. I first try this tobacco when first started smoking and thought it was great tobacco reordered a tin and now I don't like it that much, too bitter for me, it does have a really nice apricot scent.
Dunhills Early morning Pipe To bitter of a tobacco flavour like dorchester great tobacco when first began smoking and now not so great for me.
I don't like aromatics, burn too hot and taste nothing like what the tin smells like and some give me a head ache.
I have tried many more but I can't remember as of right now, I'm sure your getting a feel of what direction I should be going. When I first began to smoke and now, when retrying these same tobacco my palette has changed considerably.
Greatly appreciate some recommendations on what I may be looking for.
I am a new smoker going on 5 months and on the hunt for a great tobacco, but it's getting a little out of control the amount of tobacco I am starting to collect and not liking. I need your recommendation on a tobacco that is satisfying and tastes great.
At the moment I enjoy Squadron leader which to me is mild and tasty, ( but missing something, don't know what it is though) I also like McClellan Wilderness a Very satisfying smoke but slightly over the top in smoke flavors.
What I'm looking for would be between Squadron leader and Wilderness....if that is possible. I know the tobacco conisuers on here can figure it out.
Tobacco I've tried and won't buy again, I would reconsider on the best brown (great tobacco).
Larry's blend. To light in flavour.
Samuel Gawith Best brown Flake. Great tobacco but the nicotine is to much.
Frog Morton. Mild, something is missing with this tobacco.
Chelsea morning. Not for me can't remember why, it's been a while since I've tried it - lets just say not a memorable smoke.
Solani Silver label 660. Good smoke, not to smooth not a rounded smoke for me.
Captain Earle's Honor blend. Good smoke still a little edgy not rounded tobacco flavour.
Esotrica Dorchester. I first try this tobacco when first started smoking and thought it was great tobacco reordered a tin and now I don't like it that much, too bitter for me, it does have a really nice apricot scent.
Dunhills Early morning Pipe To bitter of a tobacco flavour like dorchester great tobacco when first began smoking and now not so great for me.
I don't like aromatics, burn too hot and taste nothing like what the tin smells like and some give me a head ache.
I have tried many more but I can't remember as of right now, I'm sure your getting a feel of what direction I should be going. When I first began to smoke and now, when retrying these same tobacco my palette has changed considerably.
Greatly appreciate some recommendations on what I may be looking for.
Last edited:
