I am a fan of the bath soap. Its nice and sudsy and has the clean smell of the shaving soap (and not nearly as tempermental!). My skin is clean and moisturized, or at least the best moisturized of all the other bath soaps I've used.
I used a whole bar of the bath soap and really enjoyed, just haven't gotten around to ordering another. It was a large bar but I do think I used it up quickly...
I found the bar soap to be just okay. Scent was more feminine to my nose than the shaving soap (which makes sense). It was pretty solid from a moisturizing POV, but the scent just wasn't enough to make me come back for more. There are plenty of soaps that are just as good that smell better and are cheaper.