What's new

Mikes soap review

First thing a person notices about the soap is the big tin container that it comes in measuring approximately 4" across. Making it excellent for travel. Also this size allows for the natural movement of the wrist while swirling & loading the brush. Flipping it over one reads this unscented soap ingredients as follows: Distilled water, saponified tallow, steric acid, vegetable glycerin, saponified kokum butter, avocado oil, shea butter, lanolin, saponified coconut oil, kaolin clay, and vitamin E.
All good ingredients for sure.

My choice of shave: Apollo razor & Gillette blacks.

Scent: reminds me of wet flour dough with an undertone of olive oil mixed. Not entirely bad as I like dough. Color of the soap is light tan. While shaving the scent stayed constant from it's initial opening.

My initial pick was to pair this soap with my SOC boar brush with a good ten minute soak in hot water. Seeing that this soap was somewhat hard I figured that this soap needed a boar to attack it. WAS I DISAPPOINTED! (2nd pic) As you can see in my initial lather of the soap with my boar this was one pathetic soap. Not for trying! What's pictured was my fourth attempt and close to a minute of load time. So I continued on with what little lather was given up by this combination even going to the point of gathering lather from the inside of the tin. Tried the hot water trick on top of the soap, hot boar brush, extra water and nothing was producing results. :letterk2:
The positive that I gathered from this soap even during this epic failure of lather was how slick it was which allowed me to do my usual four pass shave without any hiccups. Lather was thin and very slick while cushion was non existent. Also a plus no tingly feeling during my shave which I usually get from extended exposure as I take my time shaving. Somewhere in the twenty minute range. So as I did my last pass I thought " this can't be right". Looking at my arsenal of brushes, a whole five, I picked the floppiest one I had as I've had excellent results with it in the past. Also, I knew on my first run this was one thirsty soap and the floppy held water while not releasing it. Soaking it for the duration of my final pass and blade buffing I put it under the hot water one final time for an attack on the soap.

BOOM!(3rd pic)

Lather was building at a more respectable pace that's more in line with this soaps reputation. As you can see in the following photo's the difference is amazing. Although I didn't get to shave with this batch of lather one can summarize a better cushion while shaving then that of my earlier attempts with the boar. Combined with its slickness and the better cushion I believe it's a winner.(4th pic) Now to bring it all together in one shave.

Post shave feel: surprisingly with the above ingredients listed I was wondering if it would leave my face "greasy'. Nothing to worry about. Left with a bbs shave I added Lucido with good results.
:thumbup1:


 

Attachments

  • $Mikes soap 2.jpg
    $Mikes soap 2.jpg
    26.6 KB · Views: 565
  • $Mkes soap 3.jpg
    $Mkes soap 3.jpg
    29.3 KB · Views: 528
  • $Mkes soap 4.jpg
    $Mkes soap 4.jpg
    24.5 KB · Views: 432
  • $Mikes soap 5.jpg
    $Mikes soap 5.jpg
    34.8 KB · Views: 539
Nice write up.

This is a very thirsty soap. I get good results with all my brushes, but the key is not to dry them out too much prior to loading. I use a SOC or a SOC 2000 frequently, and after I let it soak a while I just hold it until it stops dripping a continuous stream of water, then load. It'll also load nicely with a 2 2 band badger or a silvertip, in my experience. Again, don't let the brush dry out too much.
 
Nice write up.

This is a very thirsty soap. I get good results with all my brushes, but the key is not to dry them out too much prior to loading. I use a SOC or a SOC 2000 frequently, and after I let it soak a while I just hold it until it stops dripping a continuous stream of water, then load. It'll also load nicely with a 2 2 band badger or a silvertip, in my experience. Again, don't let the brush dry out too much.

Thanks!

All good points you made! This also emphasizes the need to have more than one brush in :your rotation for lathering various soaps. Just wish I knew how I could have succeeded with the soc cherry. Four attempts and came up whiffing.
 
I get excellent lather from either my $10 Omega boar brush or my Muhle HJM black fibre brush, the former having much more backbone than the latter. With either brush, I pre-wet the soap's surface, use a squeezed and shaken damp brush, and load for 75-90 seconds, occasionally wetting the brush tips while loading, and then face lather, again occasionally wetting the brush tips. The resulting lather is at least as good if not better than the best of my other 25+ soaps, and the post-shave feel is the best of any of them. The trick I've found is to load Mike's for longer than average. The results are worth it.
 
I like your honest review. I always get the feeling that some members tend to write glowing reviews of products solely based on its reputation. You showed both the good and bad in yours, I appreciate that.
 
When I lather Mike's with a boar, I will swirl on the puck for about ten seconds then add a little water on top of the puck. I swirl again, add more water then repeat a third time. I get very good results this way. Today, I used Mike's with my Semogue 610 and had plenty of lather for my two pass plus touch-ups shave after thirty seconds af loading..
 
I've never had a problem lathering it with boar or badger. Specifically, an SOC should work very well in my experience.

My personal recipe is 100 swirls on the puck and a few drops of water in the bowl if bowl lathering. Add in a little water at a time as needed.

Nice honest review. Thanks for posting.
 
I like your honest review. I always get the feeling that some members tend to write glowing reviews of products solely based on its reputation. You showed both the good and bad in yours, I appreciate that.


Thanks for all the comments guys.
Bry,
To a degree that's true. On the other hand I wanted to show the difficulties or the work in progress that a newbie would experience without the benefit of experience under their um, brush. Usually I can figure out a soap pretty quick and in my case luck in picking the right brush was 90%. Also, I didn't want to post photo's only of my success once I got the soap dialed in then say "WHAT A GREAT SOAP!". Again, thanks for your kind comments & the read.
 
I just tried a sample of orange, cedarwood and pepper. Nice lather, but I can't say I loved the scent, but it was pleasant. I felt it was more sweet than spicy.

I tend to like croaps and this was no letdown, but I don't see myself astounded. I have 4 more scent samples to go through.
 
Top Bottom