Mama Bear's colognes

[justinp]

Are these any good? There are very few reviews of them in the review section or on Basenotes. I'm particularly interested in the "Dublin Tweed" GIT knockoff if anyone's tried it, but I mostly just want to know, in general, if they are high quality and well-assembled scents.

Thoughts?

 

[SmoovD]

It has been a few years since I last used them. Bought them, didn't care for them and gave them away. They were not very interesting, IMHO. I have tried the GIT knock-off and it smells like a GIT knock-off. These were the pre-Gary edts so maybe Sue's entire line has been revamped.

 

[djmike523]

I purchased her D-tweed a few months ago. Does it smell identical to GIT? No. Does it smell close enough, particularly considering its ~ 1/25 the cost? Absolutely.

 

[Smoothcriminal]

I got these 2 and must say I quite like them - I think for the price they are a good quality and pleasant.....in fact anyone after a musky cologne I strongly recomend the dragonsblood (the mrs loves it ) the dublin tweed whilst ok doesn't do it for me (or the mrs) but I've paid alot more for worse on occasions

 

[markb]

I have her Ye Olde Barbershoppe cologne and like it very much! Will be getting Spellbound Woods soon.

 

[justinp]

Thanks everyone. Any idea if she sells samples?

 

[kmfrank]

I've heard some good things about her soaps, and for the price it seemed a good investment for me to try them out.

I ordered Dragon's Blood and Spellbound Woods, and requested samples of her take on GIT and SMW, along with the Olde Barber Shoppe.

Not sure if I'll get the samples, but I'm hopeful, as getting close to a Creed scent for 1/25 the cost would be very nice