Looking for a low scented aftershave balm

[BullGoose]

I believe AOS still has an unscented balm. You can stop by the store and give it a sniff.

They do indeed. Other excellent low scent balms include Village Barber, Baume.be and D.R. Harris aftershave milk.

 

[Marcall]

I would recommend Zirhh "soothe" it's absolutely transparent, no scent at all and works amazingly well. Pretty pricey though but absolutely scentless.

 

[The Count]

I've been on a similar quest of late. In addition to trying the AoS unscented and the Nivea balm that have been recommended by others, I recently picked up a bottle of Truefitt and Hill's "Classic" Aftershave balm. The 200ml bottle is $48 from T&H (compared to their scented ASBs which are $48 for a 100ml bottle), and it seems to work quite well.

 

[TheVez2]

Nivea Sensitive balm is great and has no scent. Myrsol Emulsion is very lightly scented and very lightly mentholated. Feels great and doesn't compete with colognes.

Truefitt & Hill balms feel amazing, the best I've used. They have a great scent, that doesn't last very long. A downfall in my mind, but may be what you're looking for.