What's new

Honing with sandpaper

Hey Guys, thought I'd just share my experience. I've been straight shaving for about 4 years but only recently found the shave forums, go figure.
I have a stainless solingen (dovo?) blade, it says Renaissance in black etch.
Anyway, I've been using leather stretched over wood with a jewelers rouge polishing paste the entire 4 years without honing at all. I did start to favor the tip and heel as they were sharper so progressively I started shaving with quite a blunt blade.

Reading the sections on honing (thanks to everybody) I decided it's time to try. I have a Lansky sharpening system for my knives but the stones are way too narrow for this. With no access to anything else and with a blunt razor, I decided on fine sandpaper. I figured I couldn't make it worse.

Starting with 1200 grit, I stretched it over some plate glass (round the edges with a diamond thingy first) taped it underneath to keep it taught and wet it slightly with water and a little liquid hand soap. All went well, I thought, after using a piece of 4/0 polishing paper and my strop it shaved hairs off my arm but still pulled a little and the middle section of the blade was still not cutting as well as the tip and heel. Reading more on the forum I came across the section on edge uniformity, deciding my bevels were not uniform. Back to the plate glass but starting with 1000 this time and not moving on until I could see the edge was uniform. On to 1200 and then the 4/0 and paddle strop. Viola!! It's shaving better than when I first got it.

I wouldn't recommend sandpaper if you actually have hones and I'm ordering my coticule from my brother who lives in Belgium but if you're stuck with no resources and a blunt blade, you can make a plan. Just be careful, I have a steady hand and good eye from making jewelery all day every day, I'm not sure if this will work for everyone.

ps. About the Belgian stones, do I need the blue as well as the yellow? I also see the yellow come in narrow sizes, should I get bout and hope it's wide enough for my blade, or use the narrow with an x motion?
 
ps. About the Belgian stones, do I need the blue as well as the yellow? I also see the yellow come in narrow sizes, should I get bout and hope it's wide enough for my blade, or use the narrow with an x motion?

You don't need the blue because the yellow can do everything. I prefer narrow hones because it's easier to sharpen a warped blade and also easier to hold in the hand (which is how I like to hone).
 
your case is interesting one. if you are new to honing then i would say go with norton 4/8k . this will help you to learn and can do more then coticule. after getting some experience you can move to coticule or anything else.
hope this helps
 
Thanks, with nothing else around and a non-shaving razor, I had to do something. I don't have a microscope and the edge probably isn't as good as it could be but it shaves well again. Supplies are limited down on at the bottom of Africa :)
 
I would opt for a coticule at least 6x1 1/2 or 2. An 8x3 is even better but pricey these days. My favorite coticule is a natural yellow/blue. I like to us the blue with slurry and then the yellow with water.

Here is a great website for reading up on the venerable coticule and techniques for using it.
 
Try going to this site. I think you can find out all you need to know about the bbw/coticule thair. It is also a great place to ask specific questions about the coticule's.

Enjoy!

Ray
 
Top Bottom