What's new

Frustration at cartridges goes global: The Hindu

I hope this doesn't turn into a partisan debate about globalization, like the post on ASR Bankrupcy :001_huh:
Razor wars on the subcontinent...though he gave up his DE razor and is buying cartridges, you can sense in his voice the nostalgia...perhaps we can get him to change his mind?

From 'The Hindu', India's third largest English daily (and if in the US, # 3, just under USA Today and above the NYTimes):

http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/open-page/article520823.ece

A razor for Rs.1,500 — that's cutting edge technology for you!
K. T. Rajagopalan

!
proxy.php



For my first shave, like practically every teenaged boy, I used my father's razor. ‘Stealthily', I must add, to set the records straight. My grandfather's razor would have been my tool, had I not been mortified by its looks. Its business end looked menacing, but it was the most basic of implements: three inches of gleaming steel with a dark grey-and-tan handle made of buffalo's horn. Grandpa would sharpen it by rubbing it against a small grey slab of slate, with a drop of water to ease the movement.

My father, having been more urbanised, used a safety razor. This one inspired courage because its cutting edges were both nearly masked. Though the all-metal, double-edged blade needed to be changed once a week, in my father's view, the blade was meant to last for e-v-e-r. When it lost its edge, he would rub it along the inner face of a glass tumbler, lubricated with a drop of water.

One of the first purchases from my salary was a safety razor made of gleaming metal and a clean, sharp blade. It had doors on the top and the handle had a knob that needed to be rotated gently to open the doors. It was one of the most advanced contraptions that I had handled till then. The replacement cost of the blade was the princely sum of Rs. 2 for a five-pack.

Then a revolution of sorts was ushered in: a model with just one cutting edge appeared. The apparatus was light and you had to buy a cassette containing five blades. When the handle was slid into the cassette, a blade would get engaged to it – and, hey presto, it was at your service. The cassette cost a fiver, I guess.

Then spring-loaded blades exploded on the scene. The blade would retract, they claimed, if they came into contact with the facial skin instead of hair. This was a quantum jump in comfort as well as price. I think the blades cost Rs. 10 each. I used to feel so guilty indulging in this extravagance.

A few years passed and, sure enough, models with two blades came. More comfort, more money, more guilt. Rs.25 apiece. I bought this hi-tech product, was extremely satisfied with it, and thought that I had found my life-partner. Once you used it, there was no going back to cheaper stuff. You stayed wedded for life.

I had to eat my hat soon, as the serpent dangled the apple in the garden again. In the form of a three-blade razor — the ultimate in shaving comfort. It required fewer strokes as it gently caressed the face. I tried to resist the temptation to buy one, but soon succumbed to the marketing blitzkrieg.

I found the trade-off between a Rs. 100 note and mornings of pure delight to my advantage, but squirmed in remorse every time I bought them. Not once in the last four years have I been disloyal to this ultimate gizmo.

Famous last words they might turn out to be. There is a model with — hold your breath — five blades. I have been eyeing this beauty at the local mall for quite some time. I can see it standing there, staring at me, egging me to give it a try, daring me to move on. I know that sooner rather than later I am going to buckle under the strain and buy one.

A friend told me of a battery-powered model which has a vibrating head that will make the hair stand up and be slaughtered. And the price, a whopping Rs.1,500 for a blade. I was not sure he was not pulling a fast one on me.

The ultimate blade
That night I dreamt of the ultimate version of the shaving razor: one with a thousand micro-blades guided by laser and driven by dedicated micromotors. It would seek out individual facial hair and destroy it without a trace and sprinkle aftershave on its reverse stroke. It had a micro-chip loaded with a thousand MP3 files. The chip would also sense the mood of the owner from his face and play the appropriate music. At Rs. 10,000 apiece.

(The writer is a former General Manager of State Bank of Travancore. His email: [email protected])
 
Last edited:
I think DE shaving is still the norm in a lot of areas of India. I work with several post-doctorates who are here from India for school, and we've talked a bit about it. Not to mention I've yet to see an Indian grocery store around here without traditional shaving supplies, or one with any cartridge razors.

One guy in particular offered to grab me some supplies next time he flies home! :thumbup:
 
Interesting read. Nice to know that our experiences here in North America are mirrored (although lagging) overseas when it comes to cartridge systems. But then again, why wouldn't they?
 
IMO most of the folks who DE shave in India do so because they've either been slow to switch or cannot afford to switch. These tend to be minimalists and are able to make do with the bare necessary equipment. ADs of any sort will be incomprehensible to these folk - why should we buy another cream/soap/razor when the one we've got has still not run out/is good enough.

The folks who have made the switch have done so because they have been taken in by the marketing - and once they switch they feel that they have 'arrived'. I have tried to enlighten some of my cartridge using friends to the benefits of DE shaving but have been scoffed at for being 'old-fashioned', or 'uncool'.

I feel it will be a long time before wet shaving in all its glory will catch on in India. Shaving is still a necessity and the luxury element is satisfied for the average Indian by the latest technological multi-blade marvel from Gillette. It will be a while before they progress to the GFTs and Taylors and what-not :)

That said, India does produce some of the finest shaving creams!!
 
Sirleanalot, I think there's a lot of truth to that. The guys I've talked to didn't DE shave because they were looking for a better shave; they were just poor! They used a lot of low-end razors and cheap blades, soaps, and aftershaves (if they bothered with aftershave at all). Most of them didn't use brushes, or if they did, dirt cheap nylon brushes. Lots of love for Dettol and Godrej hand-smeared, and Gillette "snap" plastic razors. I've actually got a couple of those plastic razors, and the modern tech-head razor as well. Super light and cheap, but actually shave pretty well.

However, there's some new money in India, and cartridges and canned goo are considered luxury in a lot of places. For example, when I relayed DE shaving as a luxury method, I got laughed at.
 
Lots of love for Dettol and Godrej hand-smeared, and Gillette "snap" plastic razors. I've actually got a couple of those plastic razors...

OK, I have to ask, where did you happen across those? (Please don't tell me you went all the way to India for them!) For some strange reason I'm interested in trying one, just so that I can say I've tried the cheapest DE razor known to modern man :001_tongu
 
Yes I agree there is in fact a lot of new money in India. Affordability is no longer an issue for a lot of people but the vast majority tend to spend their money on products that are seen to be 'in' by the vast majority. Hence, the cooler can of goo endorsed by the hip young Bollywood star is preferred over an old-fashioned tube of Godrej or Palmolive. The same logic extends itself to cartridge razors over straights and DEs.

However, there's some new money in India, and cartridges and canned goo are considered luxury in a lot of places. For example, when I relayed DE shaving as a luxury method, I got laughed at.
 
OK, I have to ask, where did you happen across those? (Please don't tell me you went all the way to India for them!) For some strange reason I'm interested in trying one, just so that I can say I've tried the cheapest DE razor known to modern man :001_tongu

DesiStores.net
 
This is seems to be a recurring trend throughout modern culture: the old, sometimes superior ways of doing things, are replaced by modern allegedly more effective time saving devices. Meanwhile, quietly the displaced technology returns as part of a boutique/enthusiast industry.

You see this in the realm of high fidelity audio with the battle between tube amps/record players and solid state amps/digital music players, in the realm of food between whole foods and processed foods, and now between antiquated modes of shaving and our so-called modern scientific shaving products. In some cases the old ways are better and in some cases they're not.

Sometimes we abandon old technologies because they are in fact inferior (such as in the case of hi-fi audio), and sometimes we are convinced to do so because the person peddling the new technologies stands to make a profit. This is what I believe to be true in the case of shaving. It's an odd and irritating phenomena, but I suppose that is the cost of (occasional) progress.
 
Top Bottom