The best for anytime is Mr. Taylor IMO. I would say Mr. Taylor is the perfect "fall" fragrance. St. James is probably the best summertime fragrance of the ones I've tried... but I'm not overly found of it. It's okay IMO, just nothing great.
Shaving Shop absolutely fits the bill. I'll have to pick up a fresh one soon as my 2 year old recently smashed my only bottle on the bathroom floor. maybe there is some logic to the current "smashproof" repackaging of drugstore aftershaves...?