What's new

Does your Cream Scent have to match your aftershave Scent?

Of course one of the delights of traditional shaving is using creams that smell wonderful. If you can reinforce that smell with a balm or splash that compliments it as well, even better so that it lingers throughout the day. Even if no one else can smell it, there is great delight in knowing you smell good, having used a quality product, especially when the guy sitting next to you has bathed in some awful EDT. However, when people post their routines for the day, I see a lot of mixing and matching of creams, balms, lotions, and splashes that all have different scents.

My question is this. Does your cream fragrance have to match your aftershave fragrance? For instance my favorite smell is sandalwood. However, if I use a sandalwood cream, I always use a sandalwood balm afterwards to reinforce the smell and to make sure that everything is generally simpatico. I have never dared to pair something like a Lime shaving cream with a mentholated aftershave, or a Sandalwood shave cream with a Lavender balm. Is shaving like fashion? Is menthol "the new black" that can go with anything, or should you generally stay within certain bounds? My shave in the morning is the one time of the day I allow myself to do something indulgent instead of utilitarian. So, I am scared to mess up a perfectly good shave by adding something that will absolutely clash smell wise. I don't want to be the guy doing the shaving equivalent of wearing black pants, with brown shoes, and white socks. Is this possible in wetshaving? Is it okay to use two very different smelling products, if for instance the cream scent is known to dissipate once you have rinsed it off? Or am I fooling myself by thinking I can match divergent smells. Is there some kind of guide as to what scents can be paired? Thoughts?
 
I don't find that the scent of creams or soaps linger after the final rinse of my face. I enjoy the scent whilst shaving and then add any splash I fancy after the shave and enjoy that scent.
 
I fully agree with MachM and that is my normal routine. But it is quite nice to use matching pre-shave, soap/cream, post-shave :wink2:
 
Not always, but I enjoy the synchronicity of an end-to-end themed shave with either a brand or scent.

But I've got OCD so what do I know...
 
I agree with MachM, I usually can't really smell the cream / soap after I've rinsed. That said, most of my software is either woody or citrus and I find that TOBS Mr Taylor / sandalwood or DRH Arlington complement those.
 
I find that Proraso Red lingers around for much of day. After using it, I splash on an AS that dissipates quickly, such as Aqua Velva Blue Sport. I still get the benefits of the AS, but its smell is gone after about 45 minutes. That way I don't need to worry about creating a pungent smell combination.
 
I never thought shaving cream scents were meant to last after you shaved it off and rinsed. I assumed the nice scents were just for a great smell while you're shaving. Otherwise there'd be too much conflict between creams and aftershaves and colognes. I have never smelled my cream any longer after I shaved.
 
Not at all.

I will choose an aftershave based on the soap/cream I uses but I hardly ever go the "matching products route" with soap, aftershave, and cologne from the same brand and line.

whoops... Did I say that :whistling:

proxy.php
 
I didn't think the scent of the cream or soap lingered much. yesterday I used Speik for my headshave. Smelled it all the way to the Gym till my post workout rinse. Arko doesnt last like that for me, or cj bigalow, will have to try my tabac tomorrow. I did rinse and dry my head before the drive. I do like the Speik so that isn't a problem but it might clash with some post shave scents.

Jim
 
when i was using the C.O. Bigelow shaving cream, it would linger for a while.

Now that i've been using the Col. Conk almond soap (while it smells great when i'm shaving) it doesn't stay too long after that. I also use the nivea AS balm. and while the scent is faint, it does smell great for a few hours. I was at the bar a few weeks ago and one of the waitresses leaned in to smell my neck and asked what i was wearing because it smelled good.
 
I usually try to keep I in the same family scent wise. But, I'm actually movin to unscented balms, so I won really matter anymore.
 
I used to always stay with matched products but more often than not I found myself slipping to my prefered items which are mostly a non matched affair. Still tend to buy things in suites (meaning soap/cream and a matching aftershave) but over the years have developed a select group of favorites.
 
I don't find that the scent of creams or soaps linger after the final rinse of my face. I enjoy the scent whilst shaving and then add any splash I fancy after the shave and enjoy that scent.

Me too. I usually finish with a very light application of a nice cologne to the back of my wrist, as per something I read at B&B fragrance thread. It lingers with me all day, but probably no one else can smell it.
 
Even scents that may linger more than others. I doubt if they are potent enough to interfere with an aftershave and especially not a cologne.
 
My main rotations are built around TOBS because of the availability of matching scents. I have each scent in bar soap, cream, shave soap (if available), AS, and Col. In fact, the only hole I have is the lack of Eton College shave soap being produced.
 
Sometimes I do match them, sometimes I don't. Currently I have more different scented soaps/creams then aftershaves, so I can't always match them even if I wanted to.
 
Top Bottom